Tuesday, November 17, 2026

I think they’re tired of winning now

History teaches us two clear lessons about the ebb and flow of the Culture Wars: first, that whichever side believes it is winning will tend to overreach, pushing too far, too fast, and in the process alienating the public. The second is that the American people tend to oppose whoever they see as the aggressor in the Culture Wars—whoever they see as trying to intrusively impose their values on other people and bullying everyone who disagrees.

Yuval Levin, The Fractured Republic

This is my nominee for “why really did the Democrats whup the Republicans so badly in 2026?” Trump has been overreaching like mad; he has been sending his enemy list to the Department of Justice for criminal prosecution; and Republicans have acted as if all was okay.

The Making of a Rape Victim

Some will, of course, claim that Jane Doe’s early swagger was all an act, the desperate pretense of a wounded woman who couldn’t bear to confront her own victimhood. Maybe so, but it was still the story the woman in question preferred to tell. To deny its truth, to take it away from her—as her friends did, when they all but insisted that she renounce her agency and recast herself as a victim by way of undoing the damage to both the sorority’s reputation as well as her own—is its own sort of desecration. It is true that one way to make a woman into a rape victim is to have sex with her without her consent.

Another is to make up a story in which she is one—and then force the narrative down her throat.

Kat Rosenfield, What the Cornell 7 Texts Reveal

I have not paid enough attention to this sordid story for Rosenfield’s opinion to be my own, firmly and irrevocably. But it does seem to fit what I’ve picked up about the story arc awfully well.

British Mysteries

I love British Mystery shows. Britbox is our go-to streaming service. I think I know why: surprisingly little foul language (I already have a potty-mouth; it doesn’t need reinforcement) or graphic violence, lots of grind-it-out detective work.

But I prove that I’m an American every time they encounter a gun or suspect that they will. They kind of retreat in horror, bug-eyed, frantically making the sign of the cross and waving garlic bulbs. Oh, the horror! Who ever heard of such a thing on British soil?!

I exaggerate only a little. But their detectives routinely walk into danger not packing heat; British police “heat” is limited to what we’d call SWAT Teams. If you provoke their response, Mr. Criminal, you’re in a world of hurt.

Friday the 13th

What the Microsoft and air traffic control snafus pointed to is less the breaking down of the world itself than the growing enshittification of the technological systems we have built to enable the efficient management of, and smooth sharing of information within, the human-constructed world of modernity.

…

Might we just be spoiled brats who expect our extraordinarily complex lives and worlds to run flawlessly and frictionlessly and then succumb to panic the moment something glitches out and shows us that our modern world is imperfect?

I honestly don’t know the answer to that question. But I do know that, either way, it would be a good thing for us to work a little harder at achieving a broader and more level-headed perspective than OMG we’re all so screwed!

Damon Linker, The Week Modernity Began to Break.

The Trump administration has been lying to us constantly about everything, so I’m disinclined to buy the line that none of these breakdowns are the result of nefarious forces screwing with buggy software, likely with the help of AI bots.

I was pleased when The Weather Channel started correctly giving me the weather for where I live. Then I realized that my network somehow was missing its VPN connection (to a nearby big city, to which city’s weather The Weather Channel formerly defaulted). I retreated in horror, bug-eyed, frantically making the sign of the cross and waving garlic bulbs. Oh, the horror! (I also connected my VPN.)

Voyager 1

I’m not a space nerd. I didn’t watch Star Trek or Star Wars (shocking, I know). I’m not entirely sure NASA is worth it (but don’t try to argue with me about it; I’m just not that interested).

But this caught my eye and, at least a little, my imagination:

1. Voyager 1 has been on an incredible journey that’s defied all expectations. And it’s hours away from reaching another huge milestone. The small car-sized spacecraft was the first human-made object to enter interstellar space, and for almost 50 years it’s been hurtling away from Earth at 61,100 kilometers (38,000 miles) per hour. Tomorrow, the spacecraft will officially reach 1 light-day away from Earth. Or to be precise, on 18 November 2026 at 10:16 UTC (2:16 AM PST), Voyager 1 will reach a distance of 25.9 billion kilometers from its home planet. That’s the same distance that light travels in a single day… and for Voyager 1, it will have taken the spacecraft more than 49 years. Along the way, it has delivered spectacular science, capturing enchanting views of Jupiter’s Great Red Spot and even an iconic portrait of our home planet as a “Pale Blue Dot” suspended in a sunbeam. (Sources: sciencealert.com, scientificamerican.com, Italics mine.)

2. The Pale Blue Dot:

(Remastered image of Earth as a pale blue dot. The full image is here. Sources: scientificamerican.com, NASA and JPL-Caltech.)

John Ellis News Items for November 17.

Donald Trump, paradox

How could he lie so constantly and then be so candid in the Douthat interview?

My mind boggles at the diversity of fallen humanity.

Shorts

  • A war isn’t legal unless the legislature says it isn’t; it’s illegal unless the legislature says otherwise. Making an example of Hegseth [for waging war on Iran and on Venezuelan fishermen] would have driven that home. (Nick Catoggio)
  • I have exactly the same personality as my cat. I am cold, furtive, callous, snobbish, selfish and playful, but with a streak of cruelty. (Judge Richard Posner in a New Yorker profile, quoted in his New York Times obituary)
  • ‘The Machine,’ they exclaimed, ‘feeds us and clothes us and houses us; through it we speak to one another, through it we see one another, in it we have our being. The Machine is the friend of ideas and the enemy of superstition: the Machine is omnipotent, eternal; blessed is the Machine.’ (E.M. Forster, The Machine Stops)
  • “Yes sir, a country without judges would help,” – Stephen Miller, the fascist now running the White House/Palace. (Via Andrew Sullivan)
  • [Outgoing House Speaker Mike] Johnson is less an actual human being than a sock puppet with the president’s arm up his backside. Blaming him for GOP failures is like having a beef with Jim Henson and blaming Kermit the Frog. (Nick Catoggio)
  • Word of the week: hachikin, a Japanese term derived from a local dialect and probably meaning “eight testicles”, used to describe hard-working women who outdo men. (The Economist)
  • A small man looks huge in a crowd of smurfs. (Nick Catoggio explaining why people attribute competence to Marco Rubio.)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes ….

Kevin D. Williamson

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Nativity Fast Commences

We Orthodox in America at least try to observe Christmas in the traditional way, meaning that Christmas (the secondmost important Christian feast) is observed from December 25 until theophany on January 6.* (Remember “The Twelve Days of Christmas”?) The forty days preceding Christmas is preparatory, which means we begin a fast (from meat, dairy and olive oil) today. The West preserves a remnant of that in the briefer Advent.

Few of us are hermits, though. And American has a fairly pious civic feast called Thanksgiving in the middle. And so-called “Christmas parties” can be almost obligatory for professional or employment reasons.

So don’t get me wrong: I’m not saying that compliance is likely to be as rigorous as in the Lenten Fast.

* No, January 6 is not “Orthodox Christmas.” It is Theophany (Epiphany in the West). But some Orthodox – notably the Russian Orthodox, incluidng in the US – use an older calendar which presently says December 25 is what we call January 6.

Internet for good and ill

Correcting the tendentiousness of recent histories

After 500 years of histories being written by the descendants of the Protestant Reformers, the Internet has finally allowed countless men and women who were reared in traditions that taught history with inaccuracies, or half-truths at best, to face the reality of Christianity’s true past: a history that is very different from the one imagined up in the brains of a radical group of young men in the 16th century.

  • Until the Internet came along, few Western Christians ever knew how radical the Protestant Reformers actually were; how, in many towns throughout 16th-century Europe, the Protestant Reformers were the ancient equivalent of modern mobs who riot through the streets and burn the city to the ground.
  • Until the Internet came along, few people in Western threads of Christianity realized that not only did the early Christians pray for the souls of the dead, but so did the ancient Jews. Even before the Incarnation, before Jesus was born in Bethlehem, Holy Scripture records the prayers for the dead that the righteous Jews offered up unto God.
  • Until the Internet came along, few people realized that only the modern Catholic and Orthodox traditions actually preserved the kind of church structure that Saint’s Peter, Paul and James taught, namely the apostolic kind governed by bishops.

…

When I write of the ills of Protestant Evangelicalism, it is not in a spirit of resentment or bitterness but of wonder, because it is a wonder to me that, in this day and age, not only are there those who still cling to the false history of the 16th-century Protestant Reformers, but there are still many who cling to the false histories invented in the 19th and 20th centuries. There are those who still reject the clear teachings of Jesus and His Apostles in favor of theologies invented by young men in the 1500s who were rabble-rousers, undiscipled, unmentored, and not qualified to be leading churches.

Kenneth B. The Internet Is Exposing 500 Years of Protestant History, and Pointing People Toward Orthodoxy

Shuffling the pieces

I wish you would bear with me in a little foolishness. Do bear with me! For I feel a divine jealousy for you, since I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a pure virgin to Christ. But I am afraid that as the serpent deceived Eve by his cunning, your thoughts will be led astray from a sincere and pure devotion to Christ. For if someone comes and proclaims another Jesus than the one we proclaimed, or if you receive a different spirit from the one you received, or if you accept a different gospel from the one you accepted, you put up with it readily enough.

II Corinthians 11:1-4 (ESV)

This was the epistle reading for Saturday in our Orthodox lectionary. It kind of summarizes a lot of my concern for people who remain outside the Orthodox Church.

In our digitalized, printed world, we have access to almost everything. The vast discourse of the saints, the details of the canons, the deeds and records of empires, are all available to almost everyone. Someone wants to make a point and assembles a long list of quotes drawn from the saints. Every word written is true, and yet the presentation is not true.  It is impossible to argue with such things – you are resisting the saints! And it is equally impossible to help someone whose heart is in delusion to understand that such a collection can be false – primarily because it was assembled by a false heart.

The Scriptures are abused in the same manner. ⁠⁠It is terribly frustrating to be confronted⁠⁠ with a vast collection of verses gathered in the service of a false teaching. The same thing was confronted by the fathers early on. Fr. Georges Florovsky gives this summary of an account by St. Irenaeus:

Denouncing the Gnostic mishandling of Scriptures, St. Irenaeus introduced a picturesque simile. A skillful artist has made a beautiful image of a king, composed of many precious jewels. Now, another man takes this mosaic image apart, re-arranges the stones in another pattern so as to produce the image of a dog or of a fox. Then he starts claiming that this was the original picture, by the first master, under the pretext that the gems (the ψηφιδες) were authentic. In fact, however, the original design had been destroyed — λυσας την υποκειμενην του ανθρωπου ιδεαν. This is precisely what the heretics do with the Scripture. They disregard and disrupt “the order and connection” of the Holy Writ and “dismember the truth” — λυοντες τα μελη της αληθειας. Words, expressions, and images —ρηματα, λεξεις παραβολαι —are genuine, indeed, but the design, the υποθεσις (hypothesis), is arbitrary and false (adv. haeres., 1. 8. 1).

Fr. Stephen Freeman

Proof-texts

I receive an exorbitant amount of emails and messages asking me to give theological proof texts for Orthodox teachings and beliefs.

Such Evangelical readers don’t seem to understand that this won’t help them, any more than the tens of thousands of hours they’ve spent studying theology have helped them convert Jehovah’s Witnesses and Mormons to their own faith.

For all the apologetics books Evangelical bookstores have sold over the past forty years, I am very doubtful that much of it has ever led to many non-Evangelicals converting to their particular thread of Christianity.

…

In the Orthodox Church, you will often hear priests tell inquirers, “If you are interested in the ancient faith, come, taste, and see.”

Come experience God as opposed to studying Him.

Come and experience the love of the Holy Spirit rather than philosophize about Him.

⁠⁠There are churches on nearly every corner of the Western world, and if you want to go study God, there are more places than anyone can count that will provide you with Bible studies and sermons offering you “the right way to know God through the Bible.”

But it seems as though we’ve come to a crossroads in Western culture. After 500 years of studying theology in the tradition of the Protestant Reformers, many people have begun to realize that studying Him doesn’t actually heal the brokenness of their hearts.

This is why the Saints tell us that the Church is a hospital; we come for healing.

A doctor doesn’t mend us by giving us a forty-five-minute lecture.

Healing of soul, spirit, and body requires ancient medicine that predates Reformation-era prescriptions.⁠⁠

Kenneth B., Why Are Christians So Obsessed with Proving Everyone Else Wrong?.

Okay, that does it. I don’t know who or where Kenneth B is, but he is consistently writing clarifying insights about practicing the Orthodox faith, so I’m now a paid subscriber.

Forgiveness

Benchmark

Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us.

The Lord’s Prayer.

For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you: But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.

Matthew 6:14-15

Bone-chilling fiction

Again and again Maggie acts in ways that she comes to regret; again and again what she desires more than anything else is Tom’s forgiveness; again and again he denies it to her. Sometimes he forgets her sins, or grows tired of punishing her for them; but he never once forgives. In this he exaggerates the tendencies of his father, who not only refuses to forgive his greatest enemy but, when he thinks he is near death, commands Tom to write that refusal in the family Bible: “I don’t forgive Wakem for all that; and for all I’ll serve him honest, I wish evil may befall him.” Mr. Tulliver can think of nothing more sacred than a Bible, though he has no interest in practicing anything that might be taught therein.

Alan Jacobs, Unforgiven, discussing George Eliot’s The Mill on the Floss. He considers it a candidate for saddest book in all the world.

Bone-chilling reality

Ross Douthat: You have survived multiple assassination attempts.

President Donald Trump: I have.

Ross Douthat: One came very, very close to you. I imagine that that had some kind of effect on how you think about mortality.

President Donald Trump: Yeah.

Ross Douthat: What do you think happens when you die?

President Donald Trump: Well, I hope I’m missed. (LAUGH) I hope–

Ross Douthat: No, I mean– I mean to you– I mean to–

President Donald Trump: No, but I really mean it. I hope I’m missed. I don’t know.

Ross Douthat: I– I– I– I understand. I mean to you.

President Donald Trump: I think I’ve done a good job as– I– I–

Ross Douthat: What do you think happens to Donald Trump when you die?

President Donald Trump: Well, again–

Ross Douthat: Not your memory, yourself.

President Donald Trump: Okay. You mean where I go?

Ross Douthat: Exactly.

President Donald Trump: Well, I’m a religious person, so in theory I go to heaven.

Ross Douthat: Do you think you’re going to heaven?

President Donald Trump: I hope so. I don’t want to go to hell.

Ross Douthat: So I watched you at Charlie Kirk’s memorial service–

President Donald Trump: Yes.

Ross Douthat: And Erica Kirk, his widow got up–

President Donald Trump: Right.

Ross Douthat: and gave some very moving remarks about Christian forgiveness, how you have to forgive your enemies and your opponents–

President Donald Trump: That’s right.

Ross Douthat: And you followed her, and you said, and I know this was a little bit of a joke but I think facts come through jokes. You said, quote, “I hate my opponents and I don’t want the best for them.” Let’s say you pass away, you’re entering the next life, and all you have to do to enter paradise is feel love and forgiveness for James Comey, Nancy Pelosi, anyone who you have expressed hate for over the years. Do you think you can do it?

President Donald Trump: Well, then I wouldn’t be real, would I? I mean, if I said to you, sure, the easy answer to that is “Oh, yes, I could forgive.”

Ross Douthat: No, I don’t think it’s an easy question at all.

President Donald Trump: I found them to be extremely dishonest people, very bad people, very bad for our country. I love our country far more than I can love people and people like that.

Ross Douthat: Is the answer no then?

President Donald Trump: The answer is no. I want to be honest, no. I think it would–

Ross Douthat: Before the judgment throne of God?

President Donald Trump: Before the judgment. No, I think they were very bad people and– I dislike, I can use the word hate, I do hate some of my enemies. I think they’re– they’ve been terrible. Look what they’ve put me through, the weaponization. I got indicted–

Ross Douthat: You have fought– Mr.–

President Donald Trump: –I got impeached–

Ross Douthat: –President– Mr. President. You have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you?

President Donald Trump: I mean, it’s such an easy answer. All I have to do is say, “Yes, I can.”

Ross Douthat: I– I, again, I don’t think it’s an easy answer–

President Donald Trump: Honestly, Ross, can I– can I be honest–

Ross Douthat: –that’s why I asked it. Yes.

President Donald Trump: I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.

60 Minutes, 11/8/26

Incredibly, there are guys who teach that cultivating hatred is important for Christians. Flee from them:

I spent a week in an icon workshop with the late Xenia Pokrovsky. I recall her statement concerning an icon that depicted a very grievous incident. She declared, “This is not an icon!” I remember looking at it and thinking, “But it’s painted in the correct style, etc.” She said, “It has hate. A true icon cannot have hate.” And I could see that she was correct. Nothing that breeds hate in the human heart has about it the nature of truth. This is a hard saying.

Fr. Stephen Freeman

Shorts

  • Murphy’s Armageddon Observation: Those who don’t learn from the past are condemned to write end-times books. Corollary: God doesn’t read prophecy books. (Mark A. Noll, The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind)
  • [E]vangelicals need to embrace Christian realism. Their theology tells them the world and human nature are fallen, and the church is always a minority force within society, but their expectations are often utopian.⁠⁠ (Mark Tooley)

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Tripleplus Ungood

I’m not aware of a lot of things, and one of them is anyone else making the point I’m about to make.

Trump’s defeat on November 3 was so comprehensive that Republicans ought to be totally fortified against heeding him in the future.

First, the voters repudiated the Republican Party because of the stuff Donald Trump did that pissed them off and the Republicans’ complicity in it.

Second, the Republican wipeout was worse than it needed to be because one of the things Donald Trump commanded Republicans to do was an unprecedented mid-decade redistricting, in the course of which they structurally disadvantaged themselves in a way that would cost them heavily in a blue wave election — not just in 2026 but any blue wave election before the next redistricting, which normally would include 2028 and 2030. This was a known risk to anyone with an IQ above that of a Gerbil, which, alas, excludes our President, who rules the GOP with a tiny iron paw (except in Indiana, bless ’em).

Third, the Democrats now bode well to be in control of an unusual number of statehouses in 2031, when the next redistricting is customarily expected.

So Republicans can’t completely blame Trump because they all are at least theoretically grown-ups, but they were following his orders, which proved tripleplus ungood.


Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes ….

Kevin D. Williamson

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Veterans Day

TPUSA

I paid no conscious attention to Turning Point USA (TPUSA) before Charlie Kirk’s murder 14 months ago and only a little (unfavorable) attention to Charlie Kirk, who I knew exclusively as somebody who’d teamed up with the (execrable) Jerry Falwell, Jr. to create a “FalKirk Center” at Liberty University. After Kirk’s murder, I paid a little attention for a little while and then drifted back into indifference.

Now TPUSA is back in the commentary. It seems that TPUSA started off as essentially Reaganite conservative, but fell in with a bad set, as foolish youth are wont to do, and hitched their star to MAGA, forsaking conservatism for the populist fad. There doubtless are non-Reaganite conservatisms, but I’m not sure there’s even one MAGA conservatism, so I cannot take TPUSA seriously a flavor of conservatism, even if I once might have done had I been paying attention.

Anyway, part of the TPUSA plan was to mobilize young voters. They did, but young voters turned blue last week. Oops!

Instead of vindicating a polarizing organization that has pitched itself as the future of the G.O.P., Tuesday’s results set off recriminations from establishment Republicans who have been exiled by Turning Point’s political machine.

“Turning Point is driving us to extinction,” said Gina Swoboda, the former Arizona Republican Party chairwoman who has feuded with the group. “They have become a destructive force in Republican politics.”

In the days since Republicans’ blowout loss, Turning Point leaders have been left to sift through the rubble of the “red wall” they had pledged to build in Arizona, Nevada and New Hampshire, states they view as critical battlegrounds. Despite the group’s significant investment, the only high-profile candidate in those three states who won with its backing was Kelly Ayotte, the incumbent governor of New Hampshire.

…

In a social media post, Erika Kirk, Mr. Kirk’s widow and Turning Point’s chief executive, said it was clear voters were “concerned about the state of the economy and the war in Iran.” The group’s leaders, she said, were poring over election results and would “spend the next two years making the case for how conservative, free market solutions, and a renewed focus on our country’s founding principles can address the problems the American people face.”

Turning Point Bet on the Midterms and Lost. Some Republicans Are Furious. (The New York Times)

I kinda like that last block-quoted paragraph. “Conservative, free market solutions, and a renewed focus on our country’s founding principles” is very un-MAGA. It could signal a course-correction, but it also could be just so much blather and boilerplate.

If you’re keenly interested in what TPUSA is up to, don’t watch this spot. I’m fairly certain I won’t be thinking about them for long.

Persuasion

We have stopped believing in reason’s power to persuade. The right thinks the critical social theories espoused by many on the left are both wrong and pernicious, but it doesn’t expect to be able to convince the left of this view. Hence the move to use raw political or legal power to suppress it. The left, meanwhile, thinks many of those who don’t share its premises are motivated by racism and other forms of bigotry that are in most cases untouchable by argument. Hence the move to use moral condemnation to get resisters excluded from social circles and cultural institutions in which they enjoy various forms of power and status.

These examples are themselves expressions of a broader trend we see all around us in our public life: the tendency to skip the work of attempting to change minds in favor of grabbing the power to control what’s permitted. The clearest, and oldest example, of this move is the appeal to judges to resolve disputes that resist resolution through democratic deliberation and consensus-building. Instead of the right trying (and likely failing) to convince the rest of the country that the New Deal is a bad idea, it seeks to get the Supreme Court to declare the New Deal unconstitutional. Instead of the left trying (and likely failing) to convince the rest of the country that abortion should be legal, it seeks to get the Supreme Court to declare abortion a constitutionally protected right.

Damon Linker (March 2021) via Alan Jacobs (who adds “I don’t think this is quite right”)

Frantic, tragic, sanguine

Please don’t come at me with “but you voted for him!” I did, in 2020, and would have done in 2024 had I been in the country. I did so not out of respect for him, but because I believed that he was the only thing standing between people like me and the woke fanatics who despise us so much they would stop at next to nothing to ruin us. Because he was the only thing! He really was.

Rod Dreher (bold added).

I can think of no deeper gulf between Rod and me than this. I think his fear of progressives is wildly disproportionate; I think his willingness to trust in a profoundly wicked and un-Christian man for his protection from them is perversely short-sighted and unscriptural. (Ps. 146:3).

I’ve “wasted” my vote on a third-party candidate in every Presidential election involving Trump, and if I die at the hands of lefties, I die proud that I did not vote for a wicked man who with the advice of Stephen Wormtongue Miller may still do irreparable damage to our Republic.

It’s called “tragedy,” Rod, and I suspect that it, not “Weimar America,” is the ur-narrative we’re living. So I don’t plan on buying your forthcoming Weimar America.

Oh: Rod also hopes his buddy J.D. Vance (who owes his good fortune, at least in part, to Rod’s glowing review of Hillbilly Elegy) becomes President — a prospect that increasingly fills me with dread (and also seems decreasingly likely).

That’s my story and I’m stickin’ to it. Rod can stick to his Flight 93 Election — ummmm — stuff if he likes.

But if he’d like to break out of catastrophism, he can start here:

Your enemies are not demonic, and they are not all-powerful and the right hasn’t always lost and the left hasn’t always won. But if you convince yourself of that, you give yourselves all sorts of permission to do a lot of stupid and terrible things under the rubric of “Do you know what time it is?”

Jonah Goldberg.

Atmosphere of Menace

I lament the atmosphere of menace in the US that deters wise and good people from seeking office and acting of voting as they think best. The image I generally have in mind when so lamenting is anonymous MAGA-sounding death threats against anyone who bucks the wishes of Donald Trump.

But the news that our Treasury Secretary, Scott Bessent, has moved to a military base because of Iranian threats on his life reminded me that the menace comes not only from MAGA to non-MAGA (I won’t say “Right to Left” because MAGA isn’t conservative) but is more generalized. More than a half-dozen Trump Administration officials have moved onto military bases for personal security according to a search I made on Veterans Day. See somewhat stale details here. And I recently learned that Judges, from trial courts to state supreme courts, get death threats when executions are immanent.

Line-drawing

A few months ago, I purchased an online course on automating stuff with AI from a source I’ve been pleased with on other topics. I took the first lesson and then — decided I really didn’t want to have AI Agents (“Robot Assistants” in the terms of the course) doing a bunch of stuff for me.

It’s partly because my life isn’t all that repetitive unless you count “read the news, follow interesting trails, write about what you found on those interesting trails, etc.” as “repetitive.” Second, were there some way to automate that, I’d lose the personal benefit of the encounters. Third, there’s something kind of ineffable about it, but I feel fondness for humans and their abilities.

Were I still working for money, the calculus probably would be different — indeed, market pressures would compel using AI for greater efficiency. I’ve been an early-adopter; the competitive advantage of the cutting edge is invariably short-lived.

Shorts

  • Unfortunately, I do not believe that Congress can impeach a White House Chief of Staff.
  • This week I learned that State Supreme Court justices get death threats and require additional security when executions are immanent.
  • In a letter to the editor of The Boston Globe, Mary Skorczeski linked voters’ Democratic turn to Trump’s insatiable need for attention: “What happens when you suck the oxygen out of the room for 10 years? People turn blue.” Via Frank Bruni
  • In The Toronto Star, Justin Ling characterized the midterm results as a “productive cough for democracy in the United States.” Via Frank Bruni
  • For the Republican Party, it might seem a little premature to talk about “rebuilding”—if rebuilding is even possible. That’s because Donald Trump still has two years left in his presidency to make the rubble bounce. In the wake of Godzilla visits and natural disasters alike, rebuilding efforts usually wait for the “all clear” because it makes no sense to start putting up drywall if another tornado or giant lizard is around the corner. (Jonah Goldberg in an email)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes ….

Kevin D. Williamson

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Sunday, November 8

Lex orandi, lex credendi

In the fifth century, Prosper of Aquitaine gave Western Christianity a principle the Orthodox East would recognize as its own: The law of prayer establishes the law of belief. We usually shorten it to lex orandi, lex credendi. How the church worships both reveals and governs what she believes. Many theologians, especially Catholics and Anglicans, have since added a third term: lex vivendi, the law of life. What we pray and believe should become how we live …

…

At the altar, I say words I did not write, on a calendar I did not choose, in a rite designed to protect the congregation from my personality. Our celebration of the Eucharist, the Divine Liturgy is a prime example of a healthy institution: Its highly formal, ritualized structure and prescribed gestures leave no room for arbitrary innovation. But its anonymity is not cold. It forms us, because it puts the church’s common life ahead of anyone’s charisma.

Gregory Jensen

It feels like years since I cited the maxim lex orandi, lex credendi, but it’s a terribly important principle that I thought about a lot until, I guess, it sank into my bones.

In the most blunt and personal terms, if I want a faith that is sober and balanced, I should avail myself of worship that is sober and balanced. And I can’t imagine wanting to have the kind of faith that seems like the eventuality of loud, adrenaline-generating services. That feels crypto-pagan to me, a better build-up for copulating with a temple prostitute than for receiving the body and blood of Jesus Christ.

Like I said: blunt and personal. I am aware that there is non-Orthodox worship that doesn’t have that vibe, but there’s a lot that does.

Clanging gongs, crashing cymbals

Meekness is not a modern virtue. Our noisy world tends to notice the loudest and brashest voices, those whose demands are accompanied by whatever power can be leveraged. We value champions and winners, and, at best, offer pity to those who cannot overcome their meekness. I suspect that most people do not believe that God is meek. No doubt, some who are reading this are already preparing their challenges, citing the cleansing of the Temple or the plagues of Egypt. Such challenges are mere intellectual toys, not rooted in our actual experience of God.

…

It is clear that the presence of God seems obvious to some, while remaining “hidden” to others. What seems clear to me is that God seeks to draw us to Him through (first) our desire. Though He has utterly poured Himself out for us on the altar of the Cross (and continues to do so), He nevertheless waits patiently for us to seek Him in return.
More than this, in His patience, He invites us into a life of meekness as well.

…

When Christ cautioned the people not to make Him known (Matt. 12:17) it was, the gospel writer said, to fulfill the prophecy of Isaiah (42:1-3):

“Behold! My Servant whom I have chosen,
My Beloved in whom My soul is well pleased!
I will put My Spirit upon Him,
And He will declare justice to the Gentiles.
He will not quarrel nor cry out,
Nor will anyone hear His voice in the streets.
A bruised reed He will not break,
And a dimly burning wick He will not quench,
Till He sends forth justice to victory;
And in His name Gentiles will trust.” (Matt. 12:18-21)

He is still “not known” by the mighty – and the rich He sends away empty – until they find Him among the meek.

Fr. Stephen Freeman

“Pastors”

The Western World is quite literally dotted across it’s landscapes with a myriad of buildings that call themselves “church”, with pastor’s who preach from what they call the Bible, yet it is uncanny how few of these places actually know what their Bibles teach about discipleship and being a spiritual father.

Gentle reader, the vast majority of churches across the Western World look like classrooms; they have far more in common with a University lecture hall then they do with anything that Jesus and the Apostles were doing in the first century. They somehow think that by throwing in a few songs alongside their forty five minute lecture, they have somehow transformed themselves into a first century Christian church.

…

It is rather shocking in a way that mega-church preachers call themselves “pastor”. A word that any first year greek student knows is rooted in the idea of shepherding. When exactly or where exactly is the shepherding of the mega church pastor’s 10,000 member congregation taking place?

I have had countless protestant pastors tell me that the shepherding of their congregation takes place during the Sunday sermon. I’m not making this up; they have told me this to my face, sitting across from me at coffee.

Have you ever wondered why the Western World has this crisis of absentee dads that psychologists have been talking about for decades? You need look no further than the local church down the street from your house where the pastor believes he is being a good father to his children by simply preaching at them on Sunday.

Kenneth B

Why ecumenical dialog doesn’t quite work for us

[Fr. Alexander] Schmemann explains that the Orthodox representatives were continually forced to attach “separate Orthodox statements” to the “reports of virtually all major ecumenical conferences.” This illustrated the “often helpless” feeling they experienced “of being in a false position, which was almost always the feeling of the Orthodox delegates.” Non-Orthodox delegates at ecumenical dialogues never understood the Orthodox position, and the Orthodox could never clearly articulate their position because the foundational presuppositions and premises of Orthodoxy were never recognized. Instead, everything was framed in terms of the Catholic-Protestant dichotomy.

Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, Thinking Orthodox: Understanding and Acquiring the Orthodox Christian Mind

Yearning for God

In the post-Christian world, people—especially young people—are not looking for powerful exegesis of papal encyclicals, erudite sermons about the mechanics of salvation, five killer apologetic arguments to use against atheists, or any other canned strategy. They want to know whether life has any meaning or this is all there is. They don’t want to know about God; they want to know God.

Rod Dreher, Living in Wonder

Within the last few days, I’ve heard some analysis that makes me think this may be right, though my first reaction was that it was too practiced. I guess “right” and “pat” aren’t necessarily incompatible.

Home

Close to home

It’s a big mistake to think of one’s church life as only receiving information about Jesus Christ and the Bible, and arranging your own thoughts and emotional reactions to it. Like I said, I was never Evangelical, but I pretty much lived that way as a Catholic — and I struggle not to live that way as an Orthodox. It’s the intellectual’s temptation: to live inside his head. The church is not the Disembodied Brain of Christ; we are the Body of Christ. Online church as a substitute for the gathering of the body forms Christian gnostics, whose minds are free from the prison of the body, from the “prison” of talking to their neighbors, from the “prison” of making an effort to get to church on Sunday morning, from the “prison” of coffee hour. Just you and Jesus, there on your sofa, with your coffee, and in your sweatpants. Download the sermon and listen to it in the afternoon, after you’ve gone golfing on Sunday morning. Optimize your consumer church experience.

Rod Dreher, The Disembodied Brain of Christ

Note my internet domain name: intellectualoid.com. What afflicts Rod afflicts me, too — which maybe is why I keep coming back to him despite a catastrophism I don’t share.

Far, far from home

Saint Gabriel’s First Warning

In the years of the Antichrist, people will expect salvation from space. This will be the devil’s greatest trick! Humanity will seek help from the aliens, not knowing that they are actually demons.

Saint Gabriel’s Second Warning

In the last days do not look at the sky — you may be lured with the miracles performed up there — you will believe them and perish. In antichristian times people will be waiting for salvation from outer space.

Saint Gabriel Urgebadze, Fool for Christ, Canonized Georgian Orthodox Saint († 1995). This is my proximate source, but I now acknowledge that this is the consensus of Orthodox Saints who have expressed a view.

It’s also the view of me, a sinner. I find it a more satisfying answer than conjectures about interstellar travel solutions and marginally more charitable than saying all the reporters of alien encounters are lunatics.

And now, having never experienced personal visitations from whatever they are, I have other business to take care of, thank you.

Debuted last Saturday, The Great Christian Divide: East & West:

I offer it really as a guide for the perplexed. For the Orthodox-curious, this provides an avenue for answering that question: What is this thing to which I am drawn? I’m curious about Orthodoxy, but what is it, and how does it differ from Christianity as I know it? I offer it also to the Orthodox convert, one who has said, “I’ve embraced Orthodoxy, but I’m not sure I fully understand it yet. I’m not convinced that I fully traded out my Western theology for a fully Orthodox worldview.” I also offer it to those who are on the outside and have no interest in Orthodoxy, but they are nonetheless perplexed because they’ve watched somebody else make this journey, and they want to understand: What is this thing that my son or my daughter, my husband or my wife has embraced? And so this offers a way of answering that question. And I even offer it to the apologist, the one who opposes Orthodoxy, in order that we might have more informed and fruitful dialogue about East-West differences.

Dr. Nathan Jacobs, explaining his purpose (should I say “target audiences”?) in creating The East West Series, now known as The Great Christian Divide: East & West (I guess it evolved during production, just as it grew from 24 episodes to 33).

Look at the “Episode Guide” and you’ll see why a long-ago convert with intellectual leanings found it irresistible, even at $199 (But wait! You also get a Turnip Twaddler and a Diaper Steamer!).

Dr. Jacobs has a very forbidding copyright notice on his material. As a retired lawyer, I think the law overrides such copyright claims insofar as someone makes “fair use” of material, but I respect the hundreds or thousands of hours that had to go into this series, so I’ll be quoting him rarely if at all.

But I suspect I’ll be reflecting what I learn from him from now until I cease blogging on matters of faith.

Shorts

  • [F]or every far-left proponent of “postcolonial” theologies who is attempting to evacuate the faith of its historic substance, there is a neo-Confederate apologist who styles himself as fighting the incursion of “cultural Marxism” in Baptist seminaries. (John Ehrett, Book Review: “Live Not By Lies” – Conciliar Post)
  • If you teach that sanctification consists of “letting go” and letting the Holy Spirit do all the work, then don’t blame me if you have no scholars! (Mark A. Noll, The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind)
  • Theology is not a cerebral knowledge but a living knowledge that is directly relevant to man and sustains and possesses the whole man. A cold, cerebral man cannot know and discourse on divine things, even if his head contains an entire patristic library. He who is not moved by a sunset, a tree, or a bird cannot be stirred even by the Creator of these things. In order to grasp God and be able to talk about Him to others you must be a poetic soul. (Fr. Stephen Freeman)

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Saturday November 7

We in the USA crossed some kind of rubicon this week, and we’re still digesting. I clipped and saved commentary starting Wednesday that felt banal by Saturday and got deleted. I’ve also picked up interesting tidbits, for sources I think are reliable, but for which I can’t provide specific corraboration in a reasonable amount of time. So buckle in and take some of the political stuff below with a grain of salt (and it’s not all political).

Character is destiny

At some point I suspect Mr. Trump is going to turn on his party. They didn’t deserve him, they let him down, he tried to help them but they wouldn’t let him. It’s going to be real bunker talk. It’s how he was probably always destined to wind up, swiveling around from the desk and telling the audience it’s fired.

We’re thinking of the scene from “A Face in the Crowd,” in which the charming and garrulous Lonesome Rhodes, a great network television star, signs off from his weekly show. The credits roll, and we see him talking in the background, silently. But he’s not sharing folksy wisdom, he’s telling an actor what he thinks of the audience. The sound is secretly switched on in the control room, and America hears it: “Good night, you stupid idiots. Good night, you miserable slobs.”

I suspect that kind of moment is coming. Another betrayal, another reason for Republicans to stand up straight and recover themselves.

Peggy Noonan, Trump is the Author of the Ruin

Voters don’t give a fig about being led by “nice” ethical people

I meant what I said on Wednesday, that this week’s tsunami shouldn’t cause us⁠⁠ to reconsider Americans’ tolerance for postliberalism. If the past 21 months had played out the same way except for the Iran war and the gas crisis it caused—the same corruption, the same presidential abuses of power, even the same tariffs—my guess is that only Crowley (and maybe Talarico) would have won among the Democrats I named. Voters don’t give a fig about being led by “nice” ethical people, we discovered two years ago. They care about prosperity, and if they’re convinced that a party led by abject scumbags is more likely to deliver it, that’s the party they’ll choose.

…

Off the top of my head, the only major Republican candidate this year who stood out as pleasant, relatable, and nonmalicious, i.e. “normal,” was Iowa’s Ashley Hinson. (Collins too, I suppose, if you want to call a five-term Senate incumbent “relatable.”) By and large, the party of Trump was, well, the party of Trump. From Vivek Ramaswamy’s infamous attack ad to J.D. Vance’s gay-baiting to the all-hands-on-deck demagoguery against El-Sayed to every single thing about Ken Paxton, the GOP campaign was a parade of vicious goblins offering sociopathy in lieu of the prosperity that voters had been promised in 2024.

Nick Catoggio, The Jerk Shop

Digital Doritos

Consider Doritos. What starts out as raw corn is processed into an irresistible snack by industrial machinery that dries, pulverizes, rehydrates, extrudes and deep-fries it — then adds salt, sugar and artificial flavorings and colorings. Most of us know that food products engineered for immediate pleasure rather than long-term nourishment should be no more than an occasional indulgence. But because instinct tells us that fat, sugar and salt mean escaping starvation and death, ultraprocessed foods now account for the majority of calories in the American diet.

…

“What is a TikTok video,” he asks, “if not a digital Dorito?”

…

It’s not just our food, then, that’s ultraprocessed. Altogether, these developments have warped our environment so significantly that we live in what could be called an “ultraprocessed world.”

Angela Duckworth, These Inventions Were Built to Trick Us

Shorts

  • Conflict is Mr. Trump’s jam. The nastier the better. For all his self-aggrandizing talk about building stuff, his true talents lie in combat and destruction. He long ago shattered the spine of the G.O.P., so humiliating its members now is a minor thrill at best. But facing off against Democratic majorities in both chambers still buzzing from their electoral win? Now that is something to live for. (Michelle Cottle)
  • … the broader tenor of this administration, which has utterly lacked any public-spirited vision or direction and has allowed itself to be defined by Trump’s own vapid impulsivity and thuggish narcissism, and to descend into shameless personal corruption … at this point, the president just seems to have grown tired of his job, seeking escape from its burdens in ridiculous vanity projects while real problems (often of his own creation) fester. (Yuval Levin)
  • 41 data center initiatives were on the ballot on Tuesday, and 40 of them went against AI. (Ted Gioia)
  • I have a different experience of what the human body is depending on whether the body is that of a patient, the victim in a crime I am investigating, my aunt, an artist’s model, or my lover. Each calls forth, and expects to receive, a different kind of attention, which governs what, in the end, it is that I experience. (Iain McGilchrist, The Matter With Things: Our Brains, Our Delusions, and the Unmaking of the World)
  • Progressives did worse in blue states than “normie” Democrats did in red states. (Jonah Goldberg)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes ….

Kevin D. Williamson

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Wow! Uncharted territory!

The CrunchyCon Manifesto

  1. Conservatism should focus more on the character of society than on the material conditions of life found in consumerism.
  2. Big business deserves as much skepticism as big government.
  3. Culture is more important than politics and economics.
  4. A conservatism that does not practice restraint, humility, and good stewardship—especially of the natural world—is not fundamentally conservative.
  5. Small, local, old, and particular are almost always better than big, global, new, and abstract.
  6. Beauty is more important than efficiency.
  7. The relentlessness of media-driven pop culture deadens our senses to authentic truth, beauty, and wisdom.
  8. The institution most essential to conserve is the traditional family.

Arthur Hunt III, Live Not by Lies from Neither the Left nor Right (Front Porch Republic)

Blame them both

In case after case after case, the Department of Justice is targeting Trump opponents, making frivolous arguments and engaging in vindictive, meritless prosecutions.

I blame Trump, but I also blame [Attorney General Todd] Blanche. He doesn’t understand his own job.

We all know that Trump has an extreme view of executive power that renders him a virtual elected monarch. His administration’s actions extend well beyond conventional “unitary executive theory,” which puts a premium on presidential control over the executive branch. He treats the law as his plaything, deciding on his own whim which laws will be enforced and which ones will not.

It is true that the president is the boss of every cabinet official. He can fire them at will. But it is also true that the attorney general is different from every other member of the cabinet.

Unlike, say, Pete Hegseth, Blanche has three masters, not one. The attorney general and all the lawyers working for him also answer to the judiciary, which not only decides the cases he brings; it also governs the conduct of D.O.J. officials in court. And he also answers to the bar — rules of ethics are binding on every attorney, including government attorneys.

In addition, Trump may be Blanche’s boss, but he is not Blanche’s client. Blanche’s client is the government of the United States, including its various agencies. Blanche owes his fiduciary duty to the government (and, ultimately, the Constitution), not to the president.

In the criminal context, these additional obligations have profound meaning. In a 1935 case, Berger v. United States, the Supreme Court said, “The United States Attorney is the representative not of an ordinary party to a controversy, but of a sovereignty whose obligation to govern impartially is as compelling as its obligation to govern at all, and whose interest, therefore, in a criminal prosecution is not that it shall win a case, but that justice shall be done.”

Read those words, and then ask yourself — does that sound like Todd Blanche to you?

David French

One “first draft of history”

Lindsey Graham, taken by a heart condition at 71 just after returning to Washington from Ukraine, was one of the most effective Republican politicians of the Trump era. What that description means, and what kind of moral assessment it should yield, is something that historians will be arguing about for as long as our strange era is remembered.

Calling Graham effective may itself sound strange. Doesn’t a man who denounced Donald Trump in 2015 only to serve him and flatter him for a decade thereafter merit an adjective like “pathetic” or “supine” instead? … the reason to call Graham effective is that his long accommodation to Trump succeeded, sometimes modestly but often to a remarkable degree, in making Trump himself — the would-be isolationist, the scourge of neoconservatism, Mr. America First — into a hawk after Graham’s own heart.

Ross Douthat.

I greatly admired the leadership of Mitch McConnell in his prime (Pelosi, too, in her party). If Douthat’s right, Lindsey Graham exercised a very focused version of that, the focus being Trump, but I cannot admire hawkishness.

New York Times

Until recently, a New York Times subscriber could share 10 items per month with non-subscribers. Now it’s unlimited. I think the Times is bidding to become that national newspaper for a broad swath of — oh, let’s call them college-educated — readers.

Your subjective sense of fairness has no effect on the underlying economic reality

Because I have a very strong preference for boring government, let’s consider the case of taxes.

At the moment, the Democrats talk about taxes in almost exclusively moralistic—and punitive—terms. This is an exercise in pure magical thinking: “If we do the thing that makes us feel morally satisfied, then the math will take care of itself.” But the math never takes care of itself. The purpose of a tax policy is not to pursue fairness, morality, social justice, or anything like that: The purpose of tax policy is to raise sufficient revenue while minimizing the inevitable damage and distortion that all taxes impose on an economy. The discussion can be maddening, as I know, having been through it so many times. It goes like this:

⁠⁠Some nice progressive: “If only billionaires would pay their fair share, then we could have all the spending we want and balance the budget, too.”

Pointed-headed right-wing ideologue: “Nope. Here are the numbers.”

SNP: “But that isn’t how I want it to be!”

P-HR-WI: “Your subjective sense of fairness has no effect on the underlying economic reality.”

SNP: “Jeff Bezos paid you to say that.”⁠⁠

It does not matter how many times you repeat the relevant facts—that we actually had slightly lower taxes (revenue as share of GDP) during the supposedly high-tax Eisenhower years than we have recently, that high-income people already pay a wildly disproportionate share of federal income tax, that the low notional rate on dividends is offset by the fact that these are paid out of business profits that already have been taxed at the much higher corporate rate, etc.—and people will cling to their superstitions and fictions and clichés as though their lives depended on it. Anything other than think.

Kevin D. Williamson

Shorts

  • Every American knows what it’s like to be governed by a regime whose agenda is foolish and whose ambitions are hubristic. What’s new is being governed by a regime whose intentions are, transparently, malign. (Nick Catoggio)
  • At this particular moment (and at some others in the past), the thing that bugs me most about Elon Musk is the insouciance with which he envisions an escape from earthly hellscape to some other planet. Oops! I just remembered him unilaterally throttling Sklink/Skynet for the Ukrainian forces. As a conservative, I distrust hugely-concentrated private power, too.
  • If the Democrats do have a big night, they will have a mandate, but only the most obvious one: The Democrats will have a mandate to not be Donald Trump. That is it. (Kevin D. Williamson)
  • [T]he vaunted Republican billionaire advantage gave them a huge pile of nothing. It turns out that it’s harder than one might think to purchase a win in races where name ID is very high and the public is already extremely energized. Elon Musk in particular wasted an enormous amount of money. / That’s quite encouraging for American democracy. The people are not so easily bought. (David French)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

All Souls, 2026

This is not a day when the Orthodox Church remembers all saints, but I thought a reminder that Halloween is the eve of All Saints Day in the Latin Christian world would be timely.

What is Church for?

In the vast, overwhelming majority of places around the Western world that refer to themselves as a “Christian church,” the men and women who lead these assemblies frame themselves primarily as weekly teachers.

The pastor is expected to spend the week:

Studying Scripture.
Communicating various theological concepts.
Providing practical applications in their sermon for their congregants to take to heart.
Addressing various contemporary cultural and political issues of the day.
Delivering a stirring message that will leave congregants feeling like they “got something from the message.”

…

An Orthodox priest’s primary job is not to deliver a homily every week that ministers theology, inspiration, and a type of motivational message to his congregation that will stir the congregants to come back again week after week.

The two different traditions, Orthodox Christianity and modern Evangelical Protestantism, exist side by side with two entirely different assumptions:

The Sunday Divine Liturgy is not a lecture.
The priest is a spiritual father, not a professor.
Discipleship is experiential, not something I simply receive by way of a message.

…

If there is anything that I see differently than I did when I was a young man, it is this: being a Christian is primarily not about the theological information I learn; it is about learning to confess my sins before God and clothe myself in humility.

When I was a young man, I viewed my relationship with Jesus Christ primarily as one in which I amassed knowledge about God, the Bible, theology, etc.

However, the longer I am in the Orthodox Church, the more I begin to realize that a relationship with God begins and ends with humility.

Kenneth B., The 14-Hour Sermon: Have We Forgotten What Church is For? He wrote it, but I’ve experienced the same thing.

How are we to live in an AI Age?

In one way we think a great deal too much of the atomic bomb. “How are we to live in an atomic age?” I am tempted to reply: “Why, as you would have lived in the sixteenth century when the plague visited London almost every year, or as you would have lived in a Viking age when raiders from Scandinavia might land and cut your throat any night; or indeed, as you are already living in an age of cancer, an age of syphilis, an age of paralysis, an age of air raids, an age of railway accidents, an age of motor accidents.”

In other words, do not let us begin by exaggerating the novelty of our situation. Believe me, dear sir or madam, you and all whom you love were already sentenced to death before the atomic bomb was invented: and quite a high percentage of us were going to die in unpleasant ways. We had, indeed, one very great advantage over our ancestors—anesthetics; but we have that still. It is perfectly ridiculous to go about whimpering and drawing long faces because the scientists have added one more chance of painful and premature death to a world which already bristled with such chances and in which death itself was not a chance at all, but a certainty.

This is the first point to be made: and the first action to be taken is to pull ourselves together. If we are all going to be destroyed by an atomic bomb, let that bomb when it comes find us doing sensible and human things—praying, working, teaching, reading, listening to music, bathing the children, playing tennis, chatting to our friends over a pint and a game of darts—not huddled together like frightened sheep and thinking about bombs. They may break our bodies (a microbe can do that) but they need not dominate our minds.

C.S. Lewis via Martin Shaw

Wild and wasted virtues

The modern world is not evil; in some ways the modern world is far too good. It is full of wild and wasted virtues. When a religious scheme is shattered (as Christianity was shattered at the Reformation), it is not merely the vices that are let loose. The vices are, indeed, let loose, and they wander and do damage. But the virtues are let loose also; and the virtues wander more wildly, and the virtues do more terrible damage. The modern world is full of the old Christian virtues gone mad. The virtues have gone mad because they have been isolated from each other and are wandering alone. Thus some scientists care for truth; and their truth is pitiless. Thus some humanitarians only care for pity; and their pity (I am sorry to say) is often untruthful.

G.K. Chesterton via Fr. Stephen Freeman, Hope: The Unashamed Virtue

Enabling lies, activating lies

The problem is that all too many Christians are in the grips of two sets of lies. We’ll call them the enabling lies and the activating lies. And unless you deal with the enabling lies, the activating lies will constantly pollute the body politic and continue to spawn violent unrest.

What’s the difference between the two kinds of lies? The enabling lie is the lie that makes you fertile ground for the activating lie that actually motivates a person to charge a thin blue line at the Capitol or take a rifle to a pizza parlor.

Here’s an enabling lie: America will end if Trump loses. That was the essence of the Flight 93 essay in 2016. That was the core of Eric Metaxas’s argument in our debates this spring and fall.

Here’s another enabling lie: The fate of the church is at stake if Joe Biden wins.

And here’s yet another: The left hates you (this sentence sometimes concludes with the phrase “and wants you dead.”)

I could go on, but the enabling lies that have rocketed through the church for years share important characteristics. They not only dramatically exaggerate the stakes of our political and legal disputes, they dramatically exaggerate the perfidy of your opponents. Moreover, when the stakes are deemed to be that high, the moral limitations on your response start to fall away.

David French

This may look political, but that’s not my intent. Believing those enabling lies corrodes your soul. Refusing to dwell on them is a matter of spiritual health.

Nice Summary

Their job is to be silent in a world that doesn’t stop talking.

Catherine Bauer, Director of Development and Marketing for the Carmelite Sisters of Fairfield, an Order that is building a stone monastery in Pennsylvania with a vision of it lasting a thousand years.

Not four bare walls and a lectern

… I had this kind of Protestant idea that one should beware of beauty ….

Dr. David Bradshaw in his account of why he became Orthodox

Beautiful church buildings respect the mysteries that occur within, chiefly the transformation of bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ. If we have a high view of the Eucharist, then just as we will want to use a beautiful chalice to show respect to Christ’s sacrifice, we will also want to have a beautiful temple in which these sacred mysteries occur. By contrast, a low view of the Eucharist often finds expression in church buildings that proclaim a type of architectural Docetism: God is everywhere generally but nowhere in particular.

Robin Phillips, Rediscovering the Goodness of Creation: A Manual for Recovering Gnostics

Scholasticism

The more I studied, the more I saw the Scholastic tradition as an effort to cling to the god of the philosophers while somehow saying of God that which Christians know they must.

Nathan Jacobs, My Wild Ride to Orthodoxy (around the 21 minute mark)

I have just discovered Nathan Jacobs and I’m pretty enthusiastic about it.

The Crusades

The Crusades, for instance, could not have taken place in a world in which the principles of the Christian religion were fully understood: from the Christian point of view, the ‘events’ of Christ’s life are repeated wherever and whenever members of the Church participate in the Mysteries, and the notion that it was important to ‘liberate’ one particular place where they had occurred in one particular time could only have developed to the extent it did as a consequence of extraneous, or what one might call superstitious, influences.

Philip Sherrard, The Greek East and the Latin West

The Christian East did not participate in the Crusades, and in fact suffered particularly in 1205 A.D. from rampaging Crusaders. Some historians of Christianity mark that as the point beyond which the Great Schism of 1054, when the Pope severed the West from the rest of the Church, became permanent.

Really?!

Even though Pope Leo XIV is recovering well from lung cancer surgery and is going ahead with a big trip to Latin America next week, the diagnosis is “a bit of a game-changer” for the Vatican and Leo’s still-young papacy, a top Vatican official said Tuesday.

Archbishop Paul Richard Gallagher, the Holy See’s foreign minister, said there had been a temptation to think that Leo was a “Superman, a Superpope” after he was elected in 2025 and “hit the ground running” following the drawn-out illness and death of Pope Francis.

“The fact that he has fallen ill with, in many ways, one of the most common illnesses of our age means that he is a poor mortal like the rest of us. And I think that that is going to change how we see him and possibly how he sees himself as well,” Gallagher told reporters at the Italian foreign press association.

Top Vatican official says pope’s cancer diagnosis a ‘game-changer’ for the papacy (emphasis added).

Is Abp. Gallagher a Protestant mole or something? Why would he think that Catholics, and the Pope himself, had such idiotic ideas?

My antidote to beating dead horses

Having left the Protestant religious world finally and officially 29 years ago this month, I nevertheless remain interested in its goings-on — sometimes horrified, sometimes filled with schadenfreude, occasionally pleasantly surprised — because America is deeply Protestant and I cannot entirely escape that fact short of getting me to an Orthodox monastery and forever eschewing news and political involvement.

But I’ve become increasingly aware that, in David Foster Wallace terms, because Protestantism is not the water I deliberately swim in, there not only are things about it that I’m better equipped to see than those in it but also important currents I’m oblivious to.

My version of Protestantism has scarcely been updated since 1997 and a lot of my version is shaped by my experiences in the 1960s and early 1970s, when I was caught in a backwater of Wheaton-style evangelicalism — a strongly dispensationalist milieu adjacent to a broader mainstream. So I’m still beating a dispensational premillennialist horse, though I see glimpses that it’s virtually dead.

That evangelical fads of my youth should be gone by my dotage, replaced by other fads, is a proof, I think, that Protestantism in general and Evangelicalism in particular are built on shifting sands, not solid rock, despite the gospel song to the contrary (which probably nobody under 50 even knows these days).

But mocking or gently critiquing the fads of my youth doesn’t do much good for people living today. So I’m updating my understanding of Protestantism through reading The Protestant Mind, a blog-like project of First Things with a grant from the John Templeton Foundation.

In this epoch when “Evangelical” is almost synonymous with “MAGA” in the popular press, The Protestant Mind’s principal author, Dale Coulter, helpfully provides a taxonomy of the Christian Right in America 2026 (“The Two Evangelical Rights”). The major rubrics are New Protestant Right” and “new evangelical populism.”

It helped me clarify a lot. I was tempted to speculate about which one I’d likely be in were I still Protestant, but that’s just a counterfactual too far.


The early Church had no Scripture of its own, and the Jews had no defined canon of Scripture; therefore, sola scriptura as the foundation for what Christians believed was absolutely impossible.

Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, Thinking Orthodox

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Almost all Politics, but not too nasty

With our off-year election so close, everyone seems to be waxing political. But there’s politics and then there elevated politics, like maybe at the 20,000-foot level if not 30,000 feet. I’m shooting for elevated politics or clever writing.

Politics

The politics of candor

Mr. Carter’s words were easy political pickings.

Mr. Reagan used Mr. Carter’s call for moderation as a kind of anvil to define the sitting president. “Are you better off now than you were four years ago?” Mr. Reagan asked. “Is it easier for you to go and buy things in the stores than it was four years ago?”

As Jonathan Alter wrote in “His Very Best,” his excellent biography of Mr. Carter, “The politics of candor were terrible.”

Mr. Carter’s wise counsel made him an easy mark for anyone inclined to criticize him as a finger-wagging scold.

“If you have concerns about consumption in society, it’s very difficult not to sound moralizing and patronizing,” said Alison Hulme, associate professor of social and cultural change at the University of Northampton in England and the author of “A Brief History of Thrift.”

And so we got the opposite of what Mr. Carter wished for. Yuppies arrived in the 1980s, and the 1990s brought us Hummers to guzzle the gas that people had waited in line for 15 years earlier. In 2001, President George W. Bush wanted us to get back to our daily routines and fly to Disney World after the Sept. 11 attacks. And the Obama administration couldn’t bear to slice away at a whopping tax break that makes it much easier for affluent families to spend $400,000 per child on college.

Ron Lieber, Jimmy Carter Was Right About Materialism but, Alas, Wrong About Us

On the future of third parties in America

I haven’t voted R or D for President since 2012, but for the American Solidarity Party candidate. If we don’t stop eating the shit sandwiches, they’ll keep serving them.

Coke versus Pepsi once seemed permanent. Today, Dr Pepper is second. In 1965, General Motors, Ford and Chrysler together had 92 percent of domestic auto sales. Then Toyota, Volkswagen and others arrived. By 2024, the “big three” had 38 percent. But foreign competition had improved their products.

George Will, calling the “Lincoln Party” candidacy of Greg Ballard for Indiana Secretary of State a promising debut.

George Will again:

A two-party system is best for producing broad, temperate coalitions. And when one of the parties fragments over an issue, or becomes strange by internal dynamics, it can be replaced in the duopoly. The Republican Party was born as a third party in 1854, as the slavery issue shattered the Whig Party, and six years later a Republican was elected president.

Today’s Republican Party has become weird, and most of its congressional members are embarrassingly incapable of embarrassment. A small Indiana event, unnoticed elsewhere, might someday be remembered as portentous.

Samuel Sey, chudbait

Here’s a thumbnail about Samuel Sey, in case you hadn’t heard of him and his situation.

His deportation by team Trump has been something of an apocalypse, in the historic sense.

“If you know Samuel, you know what a good man of character he is,” former Babylon Bee editor Joel Berry tweeted last week while setting up a crowdfunding page for the Seys to help pay for their legal battle with the administration. Last year the same Joel Berry sniffed that “the only due process owed to an illegal alien is deportation.”

…

Sey is a Christian, and that’s what matters to some right-wingers. Berry explicitly used the language of tribalism to defend his friend on those grounds, in fact. “I do have a tribe. I am tribal. It’s a tribe Jesus described,” he wrote on Monday, going on to quote several passages from the gospels. “I just don’t classify my tribe by melanin count. Samuel Sey is in my tribe, and he is my brother. And he would make an excellent American.”

⁠⁠For other MAGA devotees, Sey’s faith isn’t enough to earn tribal membership. Race trumps religion in this case: He’s black, African-born, married to a white woman, and “spent much of the past year feuding with a set of conservative pastors who promote antisemitic and pro-segregation theology,” per Salon. To a chud obsessed with the consequences of “importing the third world,” that’s all one needs to know to believe ICE did the right thing in moving to remove Sey from the United States. If the Somalis don’t belong here, surely the Ghanaians don’t either.

Berry sounded earnestly shocked this week to discover how many of those chuds are inside his tent. “This has been probably the darkest 24 hours I’ve ever experienced on social media in my life,” he remarked about the vicious backlash to his agitation on Sey’s behalf. “The things being said about Samuel, his wife, and his small children are unthinkably evil. There is a segment of the so-called ‘Christian’ nationalist crowd that has given itself completely over to Satan. I’ve never had more resolve to defeat these subversive demons invading the Right and invading Christianity.”⁠⁠

A political movement that openly celebrates ruthlessness toward undesirables has given itself over to Satan? The things you learn in the year of our lord 2026.

⁠⁠I wish Sey’s supporters luck in exorcising the demons 10 years too late, but two points shouldn’t be lost here. One is that their plea for mercy on his behalf seems conditioned on tribal membership. If Sey were merely a “good man of character” who would “make an excellent American,” presumably that wouldn’t suffice for immigration restrictionists like Berry to justify allowing him to remain legally in the U.S. After all, many illegal immigrants meet those criteria. Sey is worthy of mercy, it seems, because he’s a member of the “tribe Jesus described.” Berry doesn’t appear to disagree with the chuds that laws should apply differently to one’s “friends,” that is, only about who qualifies and who doesn’t.⁠⁠

Nick Catoggio (bold added)

Shorts

  • Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty charged right-wing activist James O’Keefe and content creator Cam Higby with felony unlawful voting and identity theft over a video filmed at a Minneapolis polling place during Minnesota’s August 11 primary.
  • Utah’s attorney general charged the prediction market Kalshi with 14 criminal counts, accusing it of illegally promoting online gambling, and named its co-founders, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, as defendants.
  • Any discussion of power is now, ultimately, a conversation about attention and how we extract it, wield it, waste it, abuse it, sell it, lose it and profit from it. (Charlie Warzel, Michael Goldhaber, the Cassandra of the Internet Age)
  • I think that if you put guns to their heads and told them to spell Machiavelli, you’d have to shoot a whole bunch of top campaign managers, many of whom are people who peaked in high school debate but don’t know it. (Kevin D. Williamson, on the dirty Democrat trickery in the Alaska Senate race.)
  • Americans do not have a great deal of republican self-respect, and some of them seem to enjoy being manipulated (it never seems to occur to anybody that Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes) …. (Kevin D. Williamson, ibid.)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Your enemies are not demonic, and they are not all-powerful and the right hasn’t always lost and the left hasn’t always won. But if you convince yourself of that, you give yourselves all sorts of permission to do a lot of stupid and terrible things under the rubric of “Do you know what time it is?”

Jonah Goldberg

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Settle in: this one’s pretty long.

Hooboy! Did I ever let time get away from me as I collected items.

We’ve been getting it backward

I love this formulation: We’re not facing a blue wave on November 3; we’re facing a red undertow.

My own instinct is revulsion with Republican corruption, not enthusiasm for Democrats, who are pretty directionless. When Democrats do manifest a sense of direction, I’m generally inclined to disagree with them. I suspect I’m not alone. But I’ll be voting for a lot of them in five days.

The corruption of the Republicans needs a response outside the polls, too. Congresswoman Slotkin is directionally right about us needing deterring prosecutions (probably impeachments to avoid Trump’s pardons), but mustn’t make that our singular focus. Sarah Isgur suggests that a Democrat President in 2029 could help heal the land by naming a Republican Attorney General to focus on the worst of the worst corruption in the second Trump administration without the partisan taint.

If you think impeaching a Trump minion who’s no longer in power is a pointless gesture, you’re wrong: “conviction upon impeachment has an important prophylactic effect that not even a felony conviction possesses — it can ban a convicted person from ‘any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States.’” (David French)

Now, like Diogenes, we need to find among the Republicans, a man — a genuinely honest and virtuous person, to fill that role.

AI as God

[W]hat we call Man’s power over Nature turns out to be a power exercised by some men over other men with Nature as its instrument.

C.S. Lewis, The Abolition of Man.

Public-facing, our AI Titans spin stories of endless pleasurable leisure as our AI underlings do all the work for us. In their digital smoke-filled rooms, they wonder what to do with all us useless eaters in their tech paradise.

Meanwhile, with the Lewis quote in mind, I think about the crypto-religious devotion to, and the totalizing potential of, Artificial General Intelligence. If it is achieved. It bodes to make Sam Altman and/or Dario Amodei richer and more powerful than Bezos and Musk (he who already meddles in war policy and is also into the AI game with Grok).

Therefore, be it resolved that listening to or reading the transcript of The Zealousness of the New Tech Right, Charlie Warzel’s podcast with the authors of End-Times Fascism, Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor, be highly recommended.

(If you need more incentive, be advised that when I went to save End-Times Fascism to my wish list, the Amazon algorithm suggested that I consider also If Nobody Builds It, Everybody Dies: Why Pausing AI is the Real Existential Threat. The Author? Grok 4.2, Elon Musk’s AI platform.)

Killer of thousands of the poorest children in the world

We don’t know the extent of the damage Musk did to one of the most efficient aid programs in history, PEPFAR, but we can say with full certainty that the richest man in the world is directly responsible for the deaths of thousands of the poorest children in the world — almost certainly more than those killed in Gaza. And he carries the weight of this like all sociopaths. He feels it not at all.

And now it appears he deliberately exposed Ukraine to Russian aggression by secretly hobbling Starlink, the satellite system critical to Ukraine’s defenses. That’s a direct intervention in a hot war to benefit America’s enemy in Moscow. According to the WSJ, he ran it by Trump first, who agreed, but not Zelensky, further destroying what little trust the US has in world affairs. This week, Trump said it was back to normal but the Ukrainians insist the slowdown is still in place. Worse: there’s a real lack of accountability in how this decision was made and who exactly can reverse it.

But let’s just say that delegating military strategy to a private individual is a new low for our increasingly banana republic. The Dems should not be discouraged from getting to the bottom of these scandals as soon as they are able.

Andrew Sullivan, My Musk Problem And Ours

“Teaching you how to think”

Twenty years after my own graduation, I have come gradually to understand that the liberal arts cliché about teaching you how to think is actually shorthand for a much deeper, more serious idea: learning how to think really means learning how to exercise some control over how and what you think. It means being conscious and aware enough to choose what you pay attention to and to choose how you construct meaning from experience. Because if you cannot exercise this kind of choice in adult life, you will be totally hosed. Think of the old cliché about “the mind being an excellent servant but a terrible master.”

David Foster Wallace in his 2005 Kenyon College graduation speech, This Is Water

Unprecedented institutional threat

Hundreds of US lawyers have agreed to work for free on efforts to monitor next month’s midterm elections in what voting rights groups say is the biggest effort of its kind to prevent meddling at the polls. “I’ve been involved in election protection since 2004 [and] I’ve never seen anything remotely like this in the midterms before,” Seth Waxman, co-chair of WilmerHale’s Supreme Court practice and the former US solicitor-general, told the FT. “In the past there . . . wasn’t a widespread institutional threat. This year is categorically different.” (Source: ft.com)

John Ellis News Items citing and quoting Financial Times.

The threat, in my opinion, is mostly from Trump’s minions, who have internalized his bogus election fraud rhetoric by trying (and failing, I hope) to counterprogram some even bigger fraud.

I’ve read enough about election security to think that the most plausible way for Trump to sow distrust in the election is something like a declaration, ipse dixit, that there’s some lefty attack on some blue state elections and sending in goons to demand protective custody of the voting machines. (Oops! Apparently, Team MAGA has been thinking much harder than I about how to screw up an election).

If he doesn’t get them, MAGA America will say the election was corrupt and untrustworthy. If he does get them, sane America will say the election was corrupted by him and sub-optimal. Since he thrives on chaos, he wins either way.

What are they giving themselves permission to do?

I’m not convinced the people who need to undergo what Plato called a “turning around of the soul” (periagōgē) are reachable by moralistic appeals to Right and Wrong. In that respect, I think MAGA already resides far beyond good and evil, in a world of might makes right—and where the end (victory over the Enemy) justifies an ever-lengthening list of morally repulsive means.

…

The threat of imminent doom can excuse even the inexcusable.

That’s the logic of the end justifies any means. And that logic is a perennial aspect of politics. There are certain rare and extreme situations in which the end of bare survival (facing a genuine existential threat) does justify anything that can be done to protect against that threat being fulfilled. But what about engaging during an ordinary election campaign in absurd hyperbole, exaggeration, and outright lies to justify the judgment that we face an existential threat from them, which in turn is what justifies the anything-goes mentality? The Claremont faction has been engaged in just such threat inflation or expansion ever since Michael Anton published the “Flight 93 Election” essay (in September 2016), and now the entire leadership of the right, as well as its media echo chamber, is in on the game, giving itself one concocted extreme self-justification after another for a decade.

…

What are they giving themselves permission to do? The answer: Anything and everything necessary to protect themselves from suffering utter destruction at the hands of their mortal enemies (aka, losing an upcoming election).

Damon Linker

Are to classics too white?

One of the more eye-opening documents you can find online is Martin Luther King Jr’s hand-written syllabus for a seminar he was teaching at Morehouse College in 1962. It’s a glimpse of what King believed an educated black man should know. It’s a challenging list: Plato’s Republic, Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, Augustine’s City of God, all the way to Bentham and Mill. There’s also a copy of the exam questions he set. Among them: “List and evaluate the radical ideas presented in Plato’s Republic”; “State and evaluate Aristotle’s view of slavery.”…

Andrew Sullivan, The Unbearable Whiteness of the Classics

If James Howard Kunstler didn’t exist …

… I’d have to invent him to make my own inclinations feel moderate. From one of his classics:

Eighty percent of everything ever built in America has been built in the last fifty years, and most of it is depressing, brutal, ugly, unhealthy, and spiritually degrading—the jive-plastic commuter tract home wastelands, the Potemkin village shopping plazas with their vast parking lagoons, the Lego-block hotel complexes, the “gourmet mansardic” junk-food joints, the Orwellian office “parks” featuring buildings sheathed in the same reflective glass as the sunglasses worn by chain-gang guards, the particle-board garden apartments rising up in every meadow and cornfield, the freeway loops around every big and little city with their clusters of discount merchandise marts, the whole destructive, wasteful, toxic, agoraphobia-inducing spectacle that politicians proudly call “growth.”

James Howard Kunstler, The Geography of Nowhere

Flat-out fake polling

[B]efore you dye your hair blue, you should know that tons and tons of polling you read is fake. Like, literally just fake. The latest here is a public opinion polling shop called Wedgewood Polling, which was cited on MS NOW and in The New York Times (places that would never lead us astray). Wedgewood made this statement on their now-terminated X account:

WEDGEWOOD POLLING, an experimental project to demonstrate the vulnerabilities, lack of oversight, and overall low barrier to entry in the modern political polling industry, makes this public statement. . . . Despite having no history, formal credentials, or real data behind the vast majority of our releases, Wedgewood Polling was added to major polling aggregators, including The New York Times, FiftyPlusOne, and VoteHub, and repeatedly treated as a legitimate data source.

Ha ha. Cool. You got us, Wedgewood! Why do I increasingly feel like we’re all a part of a YouTube prank show?

Nellie Bowles

Wish fulfilled

We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected. When they wake up in the morning, we want them to not want to go to work because they are increasingly viewed as the villains … We want to put them in trauma.

Russell Vought, 2023

A hacking group leaked the names, phone numbers, and addresses of more than 40,000 Department of Homeland Security employees and associates, including about 10,000 linked to Immigration and Customs Enforcement and its investigative arm, some of them involved in undercover operations. DHS said it was aware of a “potential breach.”

TMD

Postliberalism

Readwise seems to have decided one recent day to give me a couple of postliberal-leaning “Daily Highlights” from my past reading:

Liberal democracy is more restrictive, being strongly correlated with egalitarian principles that are quite wrongly believed to generate diversity. The opposite is true: egalitarianism does not tolerate aristocratic and monarchical tendencies, not only in the political structures of the state (which might be understandable), but in any other area of public life. And yet liberal democracy, being the single most homogenizing force in the modern world, creates the illusion that it alone stands for social differentiation.

Ryszard Legutko, The Demon in Democracy: Totalitarian Temptations in Free Societies

Aristotle’s Ethics and Aquinas’s Summa Theologiae are alike efforts to delineate the limits that nature—natural law—places upon human beings. Each seeks to educate man about how best to live within those limits through the practice of virtues, to achieve a condition of human flourishing. Liberal philosophy rejected this requirement of human self-limitation.

Patrick Deneen, Why Liberalism Failed

I am quite dubious about the concept of American exceptionalism. Don’t get me wrong, we really are an exceptional nation; that’s even clearer to me from living abroad. But there’s a lot of hubris in that. We really believe somehow that we can defy the laws of history, that as long as we work hard and mean well, goodness will prevail.

Rod Dreher, Farewell to Hungary, And to Europe

For the record, I remain unconvinced that any of the postliberal or illiberal alternatives to liberal democracy would be an improvement. Insert your own criteria for the desiderata in relation to which “improvement” is measured. Mine are that Christians “may lead a calm and peaceful life in all godliness and sanctity.” But I’m trying to learn in whatsoever state I am, therewith to be content..

October

How privileged you are, to be passionately
clinging to what you love;
the forfeit of hope has not destroyed you.

Maestoso, doloroso:

This is the light of autumn; it has turned on us.
Surely it is a privilege to approach the end
still believing in something.

Louise Gluck, October

Shorts

  • If the weirdest thing about you is that your booty turned Donald Trump gay, you’re doing well for yourself by GOP standards. (Nick Catoggio of Sen. Jon Husted)
  • It’s not that I’m observant; it’s just that I talk too much. Otherwise, especially in a strange place, I’ll never know what’s happening. Like a blind man at the ball game, I need a radio. (The late Annie Dillard, Pilgrim at Tinker Creek)
  • I also am other than what I imagine myself to be. To know this is forgiveness. (Simone Weil, Love in the Void)
  • Of course, the Department of Homeland Security, when it was created in the wake of 9/11, was meant to function in opaque ways and with broad authority; it was designed to be a secret-police force. (M. Gessen, Unmarked Vans. Secret Lists. Public Denunciations. America’s Police State Has Arrived)
  • [I]f you see a man in skinny jeans and long necklaces leaping around with a light show behind him, well, that’s a man who wants to have sex with a lot of random people. It doesn’t matter if he’s in a rock band or talking about God. These are ancient mating dances. These are ancient male archetypes. (Nellie Bowles)
  • The Republicans have successfully persuaded much of the public that they are the party of Joe Sixpack and Democrats are the party of Jessica Yogamat. (Mark Lilla, The Once and Future Liberal)
  • Fundamentalist intellectual habits … have been more resilient than fundamentalism itself. (Mark Noll, The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind)
  • Despite sociological evidence to the contrary, it remains to all appearances virtually axiomatic that the acquisition of consumer goods is the presumptive means to human happiness-and the more and better the goods, the better one’s life and the happier one will be. (Brad S. Gregory, The Unintended Reformation)
  • America’s wedded couples are far less likely to stay together than Sweden’s cohabiting couples are. (Gracy Olmstead, Markets and the Strangulation of the American Family)
  • We could easily all be putting in a twenty- or even fifteen-hour workweek. Yet for some reason, we as a society have collectively decided it’s better to have millions of human beings spending years of their lives pretending to type into spreadsheets or preparing mind maps for PR meetings than freeing them to knit sweaters, play with their dogs, start a garage band, experiment with new recipes, or sit in cafés arguing about politics, and gossiping about their friends’ complex polyamorous love affairs. (David Graeber, Bullshit Jobs)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.