Nativity Fast Commences

We Orthodox in America at least try to observe Christmas in the traditional way, meaning that Christmas (the secondmost important Christian feast) is observed from December 25 until theophany on January 6.* (Remember “The Twelve Days of Christmas”?) The forty days preceding Christmas is preparatory, which means we begin a fast (from meat, dairy and olive oil) today. The West preserves a remnant of that in the briefer Advent.

Few of us are hermits, though. And American has a fairly pious civic feast called Thanksgiving in the middle. And so-called “Christmas parties” can be almost obligatory for professional or employment reasons.

So don’t get me wrong: I’m not saying that compliance is likely to be as rigorous as in the Lenten Fast.

* No, January 6 is not “Orthodox Christmas.” It is Theophany (Epiphany in the West). But some Orthodox – notably the Russian Orthodox, incluidng in the US – use an older calendar which presently says December 25 is what we call January 6.

Internet for good and ill

Correcting the tendentiousness of recent histories

After 500 years of histories being written by the descendants of the Protestant Reformers, the Internet has finally allowed countless men and women who were reared in traditions that taught history with inaccuracies, or half-truths at best, to face the reality of Christianity’s true past: a history that is very different from the one imagined up in the brains of a radical group of young men in the 16th century.

  • Until the Internet came along, few Western Christians ever knew how radical the Protestant Reformers actually were; how, in many towns throughout 16th-century Europe, the Protestant Reformers were the ancient equivalent of modern mobs who riot through the streets and burn the city to the ground.
  • Until the Internet came along, few people in Western threads of Christianity realized that not only did the early Christians pray for the souls of the dead, but so did the ancient Jews. Even before the Incarnation, before Jesus was born in Bethlehem, Holy Scripture records the prayers for the dead that the righteous Jews offered up unto God.
  • Until the Internet came along, few people realized that only the modern Catholic and Orthodox traditions actually preserved the kind of church structure that Saint’s Peter, Paul and James taught, namely the apostolic kind governed by bishops.

…

When I write of the ills of Protestant Evangelicalism, it is not in a spirit of resentment or bitterness but of wonder, because it is a wonder to me that, in this day and age, not only are there those who still cling to the false history of the 16th-century Protestant Reformers, but there are still many who cling to the false histories invented in the 19th and 20th centuries. There are those who still reject the clear teachings of Jesus and His Apostles in favor of theologies invented by young men in the 1500s who were rabble-rousers, undiscipled, unmentored, and not qualified to be leading churches.

Kenneth B. The Internet Is Exposing 500 Years of Protestant History, and Pointing People Toward Orthodoxy

Shuffling the pieces

I wish you would bear with me in a little foolishness. Do bear with me! For I feel a divine jealousy for you, since I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a pure virgin to Christ. But I am afraid that as the serpent deceived Eve by his cunning, your thoughts will be led astray from a sincere and pure devotion to Christ. For if someone comes and proclaims another Jesus than the one we proclaimed, or if you receive a different spirit from the one you received, or if you accept a different gospel from the one you accepted, you put up with it readily enough.

II Corinthians 11:1-4 (ESV)

This was the epistle reading for Saturday in our Orthodox lectionary. It kind of summarizes a lot of my concern for people who remain outside the Orthodox Church.

In our digitalized, printed world, we have access to almost everything. The vast discourse of the saints, the details of the canons, the deeds and records of empires, are all available to almost everyone. Someone wants to make a point and assembles a long list of quotes drawn from the saints. Every word written is true, and yet the presentation is not true.  It is impossible to argue with such things – you are resisting the saints! And it is equally impossible to help someone whose heart is in delusion to understand that such a collection can be false – primarily because it was assembled by a false heart.

The Scriptures are abused in the same manner. ⁠⁠It is terribly frustrating to be confronted⁠⁠ with a vast collection of verses gathered in the service of a false teaching. The same thing was confronted by the fathers early on. Fr. Georges Florovsky gives this summary of an account by St. Irenaeus:

Denouncing the Gnostic mishandling of Scriptures, St. Irenaeus introduced a picturesque simile. A skillful artist has made a beautiful image of a king, composed of many precious jewels. Now, another man takes this mosaic image apart, re-arranges the stones in another pattern so as to produce the image of a dog or of a fox. Then he starts claiming that this was the original picture, by the first master, under the pretext that the gems (the ψηφιδες) were authentic. In fact, however, the original design had been destroyed — λυσας την υποκειμενην του ανθρωπου ιδεαν. This is precisely what the heretics do with the Scripture. They disregard and disrupt “the order and connection” of the Holy Writ and “dismember the truth” — λυοντες τα μελη της αληθειας. Words, expressions, and images —ρηματα, λεξεις παραβολαι —are genuine, indeed, but the design, the υποθεσις (hypothesis), is arbitrary and false (adv. haeres., 1. 8. 1).

Fr. Stephen Freeman

Proof-texts

I receive an exorbitant amount of emails and messages asking me to give theological proof texts for Orthodox teachings and beliefs.

Such Evangelical readers don’t seem to understand that this won’t help them, any more than the tens of thousands of hours they’ve spent studying theology have helped them convert Jehovah’s Witnesses and Mormons to their own faith.

For all the apologetics books Evangelical bookstores have sold over the past forty years, I am very doubtful that much of it has ever led to many non-Evangelicals converting to their particular thread of Christianity.

…

In the Orthodox Church, you will often hear priests tell inquirers, “If you are interested in the ancient faith, come, taste, and see.”

Come experience God as opposed to studying Him.

Come and experience the love of the Holy Spirit rather than philosophize about Him.

⁠⁠There are churches on nearly every corner of the Western world, and if you want to go study God, there are more places than anyone can count that will provide you with Bible studies and sermons offering you “the right way to know God through the Bible.”

But it seems as though we’ve come to a crossroads in Western culture. After 500 years of studying theology in the tradition of the Protestant Reformers, many people have begun to realize that studying Him doesn’t actually heal the brokenness of their hearts.

This is why the Saints tell us that the Church is a hospital; we come for healing.

A doctor doesn’t mend us by giving us a forty-five-minute lecture.

Healing of soul, spirit, and body requires ancient medicine that predates Reformation-era prescriptions.⁠⁠

Kenneth B., Why Are Christians So Obsessed with Proving Everyone Else Wrong?.

Okay, that does it. I don’t know who or where Kenneth B is, but he is consistently writing clarifying insights about practicing the Orthodox faith, so I’m now a paid subscriber.

Forgiveness

Benchmark

Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us.

The Lord’s Prayer.

For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you: But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.

Matthew 6:14-15

Bone-chilling fiction

Again and again Maggie acts in ways that she comes to regret; again and again what she desires more than anything else is Tom’s forgiveness; again and again he denies it to her. Sometimes he forgets her sins, or grows tired of punishing her for them; but he never once forgives. In this he exaggerates the tendencies of his father, who not only refuses to forgive his greatest enemy but, when he thinks he is near death, commands Tom to write that refusal in the family Bible: “I don’t forgive Wakem for all that; and for all I’ll serve him honest, I wish evil may befall him.” Mr. Tulliver can think of nothing more sacred than a Bible, though he has no interest in practicing anything that might be taught therein.

Alan Jacobs, Unforgiven, discussing George Eliot’s The Mill on the Floss. He considers it a candidate for saddest book in all the world.

Bone-chilling reality

Ross Douthat: You have survived multiple assassination attempts.

President Donald Trump: I have.

Ross Douthat: One came very, very close to you. I imagine that that had some kind of effect on how you think about mortality.

President Donald Trump: Yeah.

Ross Douthat: What do you think happens when you die?

President Donald Trump: Well, I hope I’m missed. (LAUGH) I hope–

Ross Douthat: No, I mean– I mean to you– I mean to–

President Donald Trump: No, but I really mean it. I hope I’m missed. I don’t know.

Ross Douthat: I– I– I– I understand. I mean to you.

President Donald Trump: I think I’ve done a good job as– I– I–

Ross Douthat: What do you think happens to Donald Trump when you die?

President Donald Trump: Well, again–

Ross Douthat: Not your memory, yourself.

President Donald Trump: Okay. You mean where I go?

Ross Douthat: Exactly.

President Donald Trump: Well, I’m a religious person, so in theory I go to heaven.

Ross Douthat: Do you think you’re going to heaven?

President Donald Trump: I hope so. I don’t want to go to hell.

Ross Douthat: So I watched you at Charlie Kirk’s memorial service–

President Donald Trump: Yes.

Ross Douthat: And Erica Kirk, his widow got up–

President Donald Trump: Right.

Ross Douthat: and gave some very moving remarks about Christian forgiveness, how you have to forgive your enemies and your opponents–

President Donald Trump: That’s right.

Ross Douthat: And you followed her, and you said, and I know this was a little bit of a joke but I think facts come through jokes. You said, quote, “I hate my opponents and I don’t want the best for them.” Let’s say you pass away, you’re entering the next life, and all you have to do to enter paradise is feel love and forgiveness for James Comey, Nancy Pelosi, anyone who you have expressed hate for over the years. Do you think you can do it?

President Donald Trump: Well, then I wouldn’t be real, would I? I mean, if I said to you, sure, the easy answer to that is “Oh, yes, I could forgive.”

Ross Douthat: No, I don’t think it’s an easy question at all.

President Donald Trump: I found them to be extremely dishonest people, very bad people, very bad for our country. I love our country far more than I can love people and people like that.

Ross Douthat: Is the answer no then?

President Donald Trump: The answer is no. I want to be honest, no. I think it would–

Ross Douthat: Before the judgment throne of God?

President Donald Trump: Before the judgment. No, I think they were very bad people and– I dislike, I can use the word hate, I do hate some of my enemies. I think they’re– they’ve been terrible. Look what they’ve put me through, the weaponization. I got indicted–

Ross Douthat: You have fought– Mr.–

President Donald Trump: –I got impeached–

Ross Douthat: –President– Mr. President. You have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you?

President Donald Trump: I mean, it’s such an easy answer. All I have to do is say, “Yes, I can.”

Ross Douthat: I– I, again, I don’t think it’s an easy answer–

President Donald Trump: Honestly, Ross, can I– can I be honest–

Ross Douthat: –that’s why I asked it. Yes.

President Donald Trump: I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.

60 Minutes, 11/8/26

Incredibly, there are guys who teach that cultivating hatred is important for Christians. Flee from them:

I spent a week in an icon workshop with the late Xenia Pokrovsky. I recall her statement concerning an icon that depicted a very grievous incident. She declared, “This is not an icon!” I remember looking at it and thinking, “But it’s painted in the correct style, etc.” She said, “It has hate. A true icon cannot have hate.” And I could see that she was correct. Nothing that breeds hate in the human heart has about it the nature of truth. This is a hard saying.

Fr. Stephen Freeman

Shorts

  • Murphy’s Armageddon Observation: Those who don’t learn from the past are condemned to write end-times books. Corollary: God doesn’t read prophecy books. (Mark A. Noll, The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind)
  • [E]vangelicals need to embrace Christian realism. Their theology tells them the world and human nature are fallen, and the church is always a minority force within society, but their expectations are often utopian.⁠⁠ (Mark Tooley)

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Leave a Reply