Tuesday, November 17, 2026

I think they’re tired of winning now

History teaches us two clear lessons about the ebb and flow of the Culture Wars: first, that whichever side believes it is winning will tend to overreach, pushing too far, too fast, and in the process alienating the public. The second is that the American people tend to oppose whoever they see as the aggressor in the Culture Wars—whoever they see as trying to intrusively impose their values on other people and bullying everyone who disagrees.

Yuval Levin, The Fractured Republic

This is my nominee for “why really did the Democrats whup the Republicans so badly in 2026?” Trump has been overreaching like mad; he has been sending his enemy list to the Department of Justice for criminal prosecution; and Republicans have acted as if all was okay.

The Making of a Rape Victim

Some will, of course, claim that Jane Doe’s early swagger was all an act, the desperate pretense of a wounded woman who couldn’t bear to confront her own victimhood. Maybe so, but it was still the story the woman in question preferred to tell. To deny its truth, to take it away from her—as her friends did, when they all but insisted that she renounce her agency and recast herself as a victim by way of undoing the damage to both the sorority’s reputation as well as her own—is its own sort of desecration. It is true that one way to make a woman into a rape victim is to have sex with her without her consent.

Another is to make up a story in which she is one—and then force the narrative down her throat.

Kat Rosenfield, What the Cornell 7 Texts Reveal

I have not paid enough attention to this sordid story for Rosenfield’s opinion to be my own, firmly and irrevocably. But it does seem to fit what I’ve picked up about the story arc awfully well.

British Mysteries

I love British Mystery shows. Britbox is our go-to streaming service. I think I know why: surprisingly little foul language (I already have a potty-mouth; it doesn’t need reinforcement) or graphic violence, lots of grind-it-out detective work.

But I prove that I’m an American every time they encounter a gun or suspect that they will. They kind of retreat in horror, bug-eyed, frantically making the sign of the cross and waving garlic bulbs. Oh, the horror! Who ever heard of such a thing on British soil?!

I exaggerate only a little. But their detectives routinely walk into danger not packing heat; British police “heat” is limited to what we’d call SWAT Teams. If you provoke their response, Mr. Criminal, you’re in a world of hurt.

Friday the 13th

What the Microsoft and air traffic control snafus pointed to is less the breaking down of the world itself than the growing enshittification of the technological systems we have built to enable the efficient management of, and smooth sharing of information within, the human-constructed world of modernity.

…

Might we just be spoiled brats who expect our extraordinarily complex lives and worlds to run flawlessly and frictionlessly and then succumb to panic the moment something glitches out and shows us that our modern world is imperfect?

I honestly don’t know the answer to that question. But I do know that, either way, it would be a good thing for us to work a little harder at achieving a broader and more level-headed perspective than OMG we’re all so screwed!

Damon Linker, The Week Modernity Began to Break.

The Trump administration has been lying to us constantly about everything, so I’m disinclined to buy the line that none of these breakdowns are the result of nefarious forces screwing with buggy software, likely with the help of AI bots.

I was pleased when The Weather Channel started correctly giving me the weather for where I live. Then I realized that my network somehow was missing its VPN connection (to a nearby big city, to which city’s weather The Weather Channel formerly defaulted). I retreated in horror, bug-eyed, frantically making the sign of the cross and waving garlic bulbs. Oh, the horror! (I also connected my VPN.)

Voyager 1

I’m not a space nerd. I didn’t watch Star Trek or Star Wars (shocking, I know). I’m not entirely sure NASA is worth it (but don’t try to argue with me about it; I’m just not that interested).

But this caught my eye and, at least a little, my imagination:

1. Voyager 1 has been on an incredible journey that’s defied all expectations. And it’s hours away from reaching another huge milestone. The small car-sized spacecraft was the first human-made object to enter interstellar space, and for almost 50 years it’s been hurtling away from Earth at 61,100 kilometers (38,000 miles) per hour. Tomorrow, the spacecraft will officially reach 1 light-day away from Earth. Or to be precise, on 18 November 2026 at 10:16 UTC (2:16 AM PST), Voyager 1 will reach a distance of 25.9 billion kilometers from its home planet. That’s the same distance that light travels in a single day… and for Voyager 1, it will have taken the spacecraft more than 49 years. Along the way, it has delivered spectacular science, capturing enchanting views of Jupiter’s Great Red Spot and even an iconic portrait of our home planet as a “Pale Blue Dot” suspended in a sunbeam. (Sources: sciencealert.com, scientificamerican.com, Italics mine.)

2. The Pale Blue Dot:

(Remastered image of Earth as a pale blue dot. The full image is here. Sources: scientificamerican.com, NASA and JPL-Caltech.)

John Ellis News Items for November 17.

Donald Trump, paradox

How could he lie so constantly and then be so candid in the Douthat interview?

My mind boggles at the diversity of fallen humanity.

Shorts

  • A war isn’t legal unless the legislature says it isn’t; it’s illegal unless the legislature says otherwise. Making an example of Hegseth [for waging war on Iran and on Venezuelan fishermen] would have driven that home. (Nick Catoggio)
  • I have exactly the same personality as my cat. I am cold, furtive, callous, snobbish, selfish and playful, but with a streak of cruelty. (Judge Richard Posner in a New Yorker profile, quoted in his New York Times obituary)
  • ‘The Machine,’ they exclaimed, ‘feeds us and clothes us and houses us; through it we speak to one another, through it we see one another, in it we have our being. The Machine is the friend of ideas and the enemy of superstition: the Machine is omnipotent, eternal; blessed is the Machine.’ (E.M. Forster, The Machine Stops)
  • “Yes sir, a country without judges would help,” – Stephen Miller, the fascist now running the White House/Palace. (Via Andrew Sullivan)
  • [Outgoing House Speaker Mike] Johnson is less an actual human being than a sock puppet with the president’s arm up his backside. Blaming him for GOP failures is like having a beef with Jim Henson and blaming Kermit the Frog. (Nick Catoggio)
  • Word of the week: hachikin, a Japanese term derived from a local dialect and probably meaning “eight testicles”, used to describe hard-working women who outdo men. (The Economist)
  • A small man looks huge in a crowd of smurfs. (Nick Catoggio explaining why people attribute competence to Marco Rubio.)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Hillary Clinton’s “deplorables” remark and Donald Trump’s “Fifth Avenue” remark amounted to the two of them saying the same thing about the same pigheaded rubes ….

Kevin D. Williamson

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.

Our most violent election ever (more)

Political Violence

Political violence in the United States declined for nearly two decades after the 1990s and then rose sharply beginning around 2016. For decades prior to that year, politically motivated violence was concentrated overwhelmingly on the far right. Today, violence associated with the right and left is closer to balance, even as it takes very different forms. Right-wing violence has been substantially more frequent and far deadlier than left-wing violence since 2016—aimed at elections, federal institutions, and public officials—while left-wing violence has been more common in mass protest settings, from the 2020 George Floyd unrest to clashes over immigration enforcement, typically involving property destruction and confrontations with police.

…

If you look at the numbers, says Pape, we have 100 million Americans who support political violence, just as we are about to have the midterms. He says that they could be “the most dangerous elections in our lifetime,” not because of what may or may not happen on Election Day, but the way both sides process the outcome.

Rod Dreher, discussing and quoting Robert Pape, University of Chicago political scientist and expert on political violence and terrorism.

Damned if you do …

I don’t need to read one more text message or police report about what happened in the Chi Phi house at Cornell University two years ago. I don’t need any of that because I know this: A member sent out a text to all of the brothers advertising “free” sex in one of the rooms, and there wasn’t a single member of that outfit who was man enough to shut it down. There couldn’t really be a simpler test of manhood: If you got that text, would you go to the house to get your bit of free sex, or would you go to get her out of there?

⁠⁠I do, however, wonder how the campus newspaper, The Cornell Daily Sun, would receive the news of a man busting into that room during the early, consensual part of the event. “Slut-Shaming Chi Phi Tells Sophomore: Enough!” Or, worse, “Chi Phi ‘Rescues’ Sophomore Woman—From Herself.” But the headlines this week have been starkly different, and the eyes of the world are on Ithaca, New York.⁠⁠

Caitlin Flanagan, What Was Jane Doe Looking For?

If I have any sense in my head, I’ll leave exploration of the Cornell rape situation in the voices of others. It’s a highwire act and my balance is lousy.

Only the vices vary

There was a time when I felt defensive on behalf of Republicans when liberals accused them of furtive (and not so furtive) racial resentment toward America’s first black president.

My days of giving the right the benefit of the doubt about its good intentions are over. Watching a supposedly principled small-government movement like the Tea Party transform overnight into an authoritarian personality cult intoxicated with populist cultural revanchism will do that to a fellow.

David M. Drucker, The Accidental President (hyperlink unavailable because – well, just search “The Accidental President” and you’ll see why I couldn’t identify the source when this resurfaced)

I had repudiated my notional connection to the GOP (Indiana doesn’t register voters by party) a few years before Barack Obama was elected. I didn’t vote for him (loved his speaking, hated his voting record), but I thought his election was a harbinger of racial reconciliation in America. Far from feeling defensive toward the GOP’s reaction, I was red-pilled about the continuing salience of America’s original sin.

But the GOP as “authoritarian personality cult” strikes me as “off” — as discontinuous with the GOP I left over policy, not personality. The GOP of 2016-to-date just isn’t the same GOP I repudiated. Circumstances have shuffled in a lot of MAGA riff-raff, shuffled out many country clubbers.

On the other side of the shuffle, the Democrats aren’t much like the pre-2016 Democrats. Who can take that party seriously as the party of the proverbial working man? It’s neither constituted of working men nor are working men much impressed with its progressive social views.

Inasmuch as the GOP umbrella is now big enough for racism and xenophobia, “The Party of Vote Your Vice” now fits both major parties. Only the vices vary.

Bingo (from an icon of the sober-minded wing of Evangelicalism)

I think it is a drastic mistake to think that the deadly influences of a leader come only through his policies and not also through his person.

Flagrant boastfulness, vulgarity, and factiousness are not only self-incriminating; they are nation-corrupting.

This is true not only because flagrant boastfulness, vulgarity, immorality, and factiousness are self-incriminating, but also because they are nation-corrupting. They move out from centers of influence to infect whole cultures. The last five years bear vivid witness to this infection at almost every level of society.

John Piper, Policies, Persons, and Paths to Ruin.

Like Piper, I would oppose Trump, even if I could discern and approve his “policies,” because of his utterly toxic person.

Let’s try those magic words again

Conservatives should attack Barbara [the SCOTUS decision affirming what the constitution says about birthright citizenship] with “the model that dismantled Roe,” the conservative strategist Rachel Bovard wrote in First Things, a right-leaning religious publication. “Trump v. Barbara must act as a litmus test for every future conservative nominee.”⁠⁠

Quinta Jurecic, How the Right Could Actually End Birthright Citizenship)

First, Barbara is so fundamentally different than Roe that I don’t think the same model will work for undermining it. Barbara affirmed what the constitution says; Roe just kind of made stuff up (emanations, penumbrae) without constitutional grounding. Roe fell because its foundations were flimsy; Barbara should stand because its foundation is sound.

Second, if MAGA (it’s not real conservatives, said the scribe who’s aware of the No True Scotsman fallacy) is going to attack birthright citizenship by trying court-stacking, the real conservatives must join liberals in interrogating the heck out of MAGA nominees. (I also predict that MAGA will have trouble finding many qualified nominees who agree with them on birthright citizenship.)

First Things has always been slightly “right-leaning” on cultural issues, but it took R.R. Reno a dishearteningly brief time to make it strongly MAGA-leaning after 2016. I’ve dropped it after being, I believe, a charter subscriber.

I am not oblivious to many problems of liberal democracy, but I’m unconvinced that any of the postliberal alternatives would be any improvement.

Live not by lies

The problem is that all too many Christians are in the grips of two sets of lies. We’ll call them the enabling lies and the activating lies. And unless you deal with the enabling lies, the activating lies will constantly pollute the body politic and continue to spawn violent unrest.

What’s the difference between the two kinds of lies? The enabling lie is the lie that makes you fertile ground for the activating lie that actually motivates a person to charge a thin blue line at the Capitol or take a rifle to a pizza parlor. Here’s an enabling lie: America will end if Trump loses. That was the essence of the Flight 93 essay in 2016. That was the core of Eric Metaxas’s argument in our debates this spring and fall.

Here’s another enabling lie: The fate of the church is at stake if Joe Biden wins. And here’s yet another: The left hates you (this sentence sometimes concludes with the phrase “and wants you dead.”)

David French

America’s got web!

Joe Gebbia, Chief Design Officer of America, co-founder of Airbnb, has given this country its first proper website. No, not X, and not Brazzers, you freaks. It’s America.gov. And it’s a search bar powered by AI, so you ask it things and it pulls from about 29,000 government websites. It also has helpful suggestions like, “Which military service is best for me?”

I tried to come up with Magic 8 Ball questions I had for America (Where is my closest polling place? R u racist? Will Bryan Johnson live forever? Do you want me here or should I leave?), but my mind went blank. I don’t have any questions for America, more like musings and the occasional yell. Still, it’s very nice-looking. The more we see the government as a consumer product, the more we will demand it work and be cheaper and tax us less. This website says “How can I help you, citizen,” and I like that. The more it looks like Uber Eats, the angrier we will be at what’s missing and damaged or wrong, and how long it took to get here. A country in 2026 is mostly a delivery service. It’s a thing we give money to in exchange for services, like roads or fire engines, and now search engines. Good for Joe Gebbia. And Hello, America!

Nellie Bowles.

Of course, in the year of our Lord 2026, much of what the government says is false if not insane, but I’ll admit it’s a decent-looking looking-glass to go through.

Rejuvenation

I fell in love again
to convince myself I
was young. She became the mirror
of my dotage ….

(R.S. Thomas, Repeat, in Collected Later Poems 1988-2000)

Shorts

  • Obviously most Muslims are not terrorists. But at some point “most Muslims are peaceful” cannot be the end of the conversation either. (@chelsssseeeea)
  • Few travelled in these days, for, thanks to the advance of science, the earth was exactly alike all over. (E.M. Forster, The Machine Stops)

Elsewhere in Tipsyworld


Your enemies are not demonic, and they are not all-powerful and the right hasn’t always lost and the left hasn’t always won. But if you convince yourself of that, you give yourselves all sorts of permission to do a lot of stupid and terrible things under the rubric of “Do you know what time it is?”

Jonah Goldberg

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.