Afterfeast of the Entry

Myth

The early conversations between Lewis and Tolkien were not about Christ, per se. They were about myth and the character of reality. ⁠⁠Tolkien wrote a poem for Lewis (they both loved poetry), entitled “Philomythus to Misomythus” (“Lover of Myth to Hater of Myth”). One stanza reads:

He sees no stars who does not see them first
of living silver made that sudden burst
to flame like flowers beneath the ancient song,
whose very echo after-music long
has since pursued. There is no firmament,
only a void, unless a jewelled tent
myth-woven and elf-patterned; and no earth,
unless the mother’s womb whence all have birth.

The heart of the argument turned on the relationship of myth to reality. Lewis had said: “Myths are lies, even though breathed through silver.” Tolkien saw in mythic stories not lies, but a revelation of the very character of reality that could not be known or expressed in another manner.⁠⁠

…

There is a reason … that we discuss a certain kind of self-centered personality disorder as “Narcissistic,” making reference to a character in Greek mythology. Oedipal, erotic, cupidity, stygian, the Midas Touch, martial, and a host of other terms within our language make reference to ancient “myths,” not as an effort to be obscure, but because the stories within the myths carry a weight and a meaning that mere clinical language, devoid of such reference, lacks.

…

Those who are “misomythic” are not necessarily anti-religious. However, their religion lacks power, beauty, and substance in that it is flat and empty. What modernity labels as “fact” is insufficient for human existence.

I have encountered such religion from time to time in a mindset that prides itself on the literal character of its faith. It will admit interpretations (of Scripture, for example) that have an allegorical or typological character (both of which seem to me to be sub-genres of myth). But, in fact, they are nominalists, granting such readings nothing more than a mental status, a literary trick. Such “tricks” are given some leeway in that they abound in the writings of the Fathers (and in the New Testament itself). But they deny that these readings are actually there: they are merely inferred.

When I have argued for the use of allegory or the “mystical” reading of Scripture, it is with reference to the actual character of reality and of the text itself. The universe is “one-storey,” something in which all that might be called mystical or mythical actually inheres. It is to be discerned.⁠⁠

St. Porphyrios said that in order to become a Christian, one must first become a poet. Poets, and “mythopoetic” above all else.

Fr. Stephen Freeman

Christ’s triumph over death

The price of our redemption having been paid in the death of Christ, the resurrection and the ascension are only a glorious happy end of his work, a kind of apotheosis without direct relationship to our human destiny. This redemptionist theology, placing all the emphasis on the passion, seems to take no interest in the triumph of Christ over death. The very work of the Christ-Redeemer, to which this theology is confined, seems to be truncated, impoverished, reduced to a change of the divine attitude toward fallen men, unrelated to the nature of humanity.

Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, Thinking Orthodox.

Lest there be any confusion, this is a description and critique of Western Christian Theology, the truncations, impoverishment and reductionism of which Orthodoxy rejects and laments.

For all the sins of men

One of the things I pray for daily is that God would raise up more monastics to devote themselves to prayer for us all. One of them, who had become a Bishop, prayed thus:

For all the sins of men I repent before Thee, O most merciful One. Behold, the seed of every sin is in my blood! By my own effort and by Thy mercy I smother that evil crop day and night. That not tares but clean wheat may spring up in the field of the Lord.

I repent for all the anxious, who buckle under the weight of their cares and do not know how to lay all their cares upon Thee. For a weak man even the smallest care is unbearable, but for Thee a mountain of cares is a snowball thrown into a furnace.

I repent for all the sick, for sickness is the fruit of sin. When the soul is cleansed by repentance, sickness vanishes along with the sin, and Thou takest up Thy dwelling in the soul, my everlasting Health.

I repent for the unbelieving, who by their unbelief heap up cares and sicknesses both upon themselves and upon their friends.

For all blasphemers I repent, who blaspheme Thee without knowing that they blaspheme the Host who clothes and feeds them.

I repent for all murderers, who kill another’s life in order to preserve their own. Forgive them, O most merciful One, for they know not what they do. For they do not know that there are not two lives in the universe but one, and not two men but one. Ah, how dead are they who cut away half their own heart!

I repent for perjurers, for truly they too are murderers — murderers of themselves.

For all who plunder their brothers and pile up wealth they do not need, I weep and sigh, for they have buried their own soul and have nothing to come before Thee with.

For all the proud and the haughty I weep and sigh, for before Thee they are like beggars with an empty bag.

For all drunkards and gluttons I weep and sigh, for they have become the servants of their own servants.

For all adulterers I repent, for they have betrayed the trust of the Holy Spirit, who chose them that through them He might build new life. And they have turned the service of life into the wrecking of life.

For all the many-worded I repent, O Lord, for they have turned Thy most precious gift, the gift of the word, into cheap sand.

For all who wreck a neighbour’s hearth and a neighbour’s peace I repent and sigh, for they have drawn a curse down upon themselves and upon their people.

For all lying mouths, for all clouded eyes, for all raging hearts, for all insatiable bellies, for all darkened minds, for every evil will, for every foul thought, for every murderous memory — I repent, I weep and I sigh.

For the whole history of men from Adam down to me, a sinner, I repent, for the whole of that history is in my blood. For I am in Adam and Adam is in me.

For all worlds, great and small, that do not tremble before Thy dread presence, I weep and cry out:

O most merciful Master, have mercy on me and save me.

Bishop Nikolai Velimirovich, Prayers by the Lake, Prayer 29.

If St. Porphyrios said that in order to become a Christian, one must first become a poet (see above, first item), I think Bishop Nikolai qualified.

The impious curmudgeon had pretty sharp vision

I am sure, from the tenor of books I have read, that many who have visited this land in years gone by, were Presbyterians, and came seeking evidences in support of their particular creed; they found a Presbyterian Palestine, and they had already made up their minds to find no other, though possibly they did not know it, being blinded by their zeal. Others were Baptists, seeking Baptist evidences and a Baptist Palestine. Others were Catholics, Methodists, Episcopalians, seeking evidences indorsing their several creeds, and a Catholic, a Methodist, an Episcopalian Palestine. Honest as these men’s intentions may have been, they were full of partialities and prejudices, they entered the country with their verdicts already prepared, and they could no more write dispassionately and impartially about it than they could about their own wives and children.

Mark Twain, Innocents Abroad

News

Hans Boersma is becoming Orthodox.

I don’t know how well-known Boersma is. I first encountered him, as best I can recall, around 2011 as one of three keynoters at a Symposium. Having been impressed by him, I bought and read his book Heavenly Participation, marveling that Boersma so well defended a key Orthodox theme from outside Orthodoxy’s formal boundaries. One perceptive book blurb:

“Theology at its best, says Hans Boersma, is less interested in comprehending the truth than in participating in it. Skillfully marshalling passages from the church fathers and medieval theologians and drawing judiciously on contemporary evangelical and Catholic thinkers, Boersma shows that theology is not primarily an intellectual enterprise but a spiritual discipline by which one enters into the truth and is mastered by it. Though this sacramental tapestry, as he calls it, is as old as the church, it is refreshing to have it presented anew in this engaging book.” – Robert Louis Wilken (University of Virginia)

I’d love to be a fly on the wall of his catechesis, which I assume will not be prolonged. I’m reminded of the “return” to Orthodoxy of Jaroslav Pelikan.


The early Church had no Scripture of its own, and the Jews had no defined canon of Scripture; therefore, sola scriptura as the foundation for what Christians believed was absolutely impossible.

Eugenia Scarvelis Constantinou, [Thinking Orthodox](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/55924593)

I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political [here](http://rwb.intellectualoid.com/). (b) I also post [some things](https://microblog.intellectualoid.com/) on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.