The New York Times’ Stanley Fish also takes up the Hosanna-Tabor case, argued last week in the Supreme Court, and disappoints in doing so.

It’s not so much that he gets the answer wrong – I’m not sure he does, because I’m not sure what his answer is – as that he falls for sloppy formulation of the question and in so doing misinforms and muddies the water. Continue reading “Fish’s Formulation Foot-Faults” →