I don’t know if Rome observes this, but we do, and it’s today that we do.
Replacing Orban’s oppressive regime
In [A Web Of Our Own Making], [Anton] Barba-Kay writes about how digital culture is a spiritual culture. I wrote a thorough review essay of the book in The European Conservative, but because the previous Hungarian government funded the magazine, the new one has taken it down and made its archives inaccessible.
Rod Dreher doesn’t dwell on this point, but censorship and sundry other oppressiveness is what Orbán was accused of, and here’s his replacement DOGEing the Hungarian landscape.
Valorizing sin and extraction
Western civilisation at present is built upon valorising the Seven Deadly Sins – and arguably the very institution of civilisation itself, defined as a society built around urban life and settled agriculture, requires us to do a lot of things that Christ explicitly told us not to. A civilised, urban culture requires the accumulation of wealth, the colonisation of people and lands outside its orbit, ongoing warfare and an inevitable divide between rich and poor.
Paul Kingsnorth, The Vagabond King
I conceive a strip-miner to be a model exploiter, and as a model nurturer I take the old-fashioned idea or ideal of a farmer. The exploiter is a specialist, an expert; the nurturer is not. The standard of the exploiter is efficiency; the standard of the nurturer is care. The exploiter’s goal is money, profit; the nurturer’s goal is health—his land’s health, his own, his family’s, his community’s, his country’s. Whereas the exploiter asks of a piece of land only how much and how quickly it can be made to produce, the nurturer asks a question that is much more complex and difficult: What is its carrying capacity? (That is: How much can be taken from it without diminishing it? What can it produce dependably for an indefinite time?)
Wendell Berry, The Unsettling of America
The Bulwark
Now… I gave The Bulwark a fair shake a few years ago. I cannot overemphasize how vacuous and hollow I found them to be. Anyone who thinks that The Bulwark has had good conservative roots needs a family intervention. I mean this when I say it: I would sooner join the Democratic Party — like, blue-pilled join — than follow the Bulwark nihilists anywhere. Say what you want about the Democrats, but at least there’s some ethos.
But that last comment starts to undermine the moral. The ultimate point here is that character is destiny, the method is the madness. There isn’t one way you do politics and another thing that you are ….
My cyberfriend DC, who feeds an astonishing stream of sensible observations, this one on Bulwark destiny (bold added).
How do you go from “free markets” to endorsing a “New New Deal”? From a Likud-supporting neocon constantly on the alert for antisemitism to endorsing Zohran Mamdani? How do you go from constitutionalism to supporting the idea of packing the court for the left: “Let’s be ruthless.” How do you go from curing gays to supporting trans activists? How do you go from being Gary Bauer’s bestest friend to yucking it up with Joy Reid on a regular basis?
No one knows. And Kristol won’t tell. His response to the kerfuffle this week was classic. Criticism of Longwell was “silly sniping” rooted in “sour envy” and, sure, he’s “changed my mind some” … but he’s not going to tell you what or why. He finds the issue of basic intellectual accountability silly, trivial, beneath him. But we knew that already.
To be honest, I’d be riveted by an essay that explained his shifts on almost everything of substance. But it’s quite obvious why he hasn’t written it. He can’t. It would require an accounting of ideas and arguments he’s never genuinely wrestled with; it would mean conceding past error, which would mean losing the pose of above-it-all knowingness; it would need some mulling over what conservatism is or might be. And Kristol just hasn’t done the work or ever intends to. He is not his father.
He is an apparatchik, not a thinker, a cynical operative. And his magazine, staffed with fellow operatives, is ready and waiting to serve their new client, the Dems, with whatever they want or need. (The one principled thinking conservative in their crew, Charlie Sykes, rightly quit as the shamelessness spread.) And many Beltway Democrats (who also believe in nothing) are so flattered by this hack’s cynical support, they’re happy to let bygones be bygones, without so much as an explanation, let alone an apology.
But the grift is good, the millions are flowing in, and Randi Weingarten is such a big fan of the nibbly things at Café Milano. Onward! And cheers!
Andrew Sullivan. This seems to be the week that the Bulwark blew its cover as principled Never-Trump Conservatives and came out as liberal Democrats. Charly Sykes has left; I hope Mona Charen leaves, too.
Taking novelists seriously enough to persecute them
God bless the French: They are, at some level, still the people who managed to have a brief riot over the choreography of Igor Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring in 1913, and it speaks well of them—in a twisted sense—that they still take their novelists seriously enough to persecute them. Charles Murray, who was present at Alito’s speech at AEI, was the last American to write a book that landed explosively enough on the American reading public (a precision munition is required) to become a genuine public controversy in the United States, and The Bell Curve wasn’t a novel.
Giving up on our history
I saw no point in giving headings to each of these provocative quotes:
In recent decades, the traditional American story has come under sustained attack from both flanks. On the left, scholars and activists suspicious of nationalism have pushed to redefine the United States as a country exceptional mostly for its flaws and crimes. On the right, politicians and commentators hostile to diversity have sought to gloss over those sins and, more recently, lay claim to the nation on behalf of “heritage Americans.” Unable to agree on how to tell our story, we have swiftly abandoned efforts to tell it at all. The hours devoted to social studies in schools are shrinking, and survey courses in American history are vanishing from college campuses. The signature event of the nation’s 250th birthday might prove to be not a keynote speech or a patriotic pageant, but a no-holds-barred UFC fight on the South Lawn of the White House.
Yoni Applebaum, How America Gave Up on Its Own History (The Atlantic)
One can starkly contrast [Wendell] Berry’s understanding of education within a culture—one that weds land and memory—with a modern form of education that aims to liberate young people from place and from history, and to relieve them of burdensome obligations to the past or the future. (A key feature of what is currently conceived of as a “democratic” form of education, namely a “meritocracy,” is today equally supported by the Left and the Right alike.)
Mark T. Mitchell (Editor), Nathan Schlueter (Editor)The Humane Vision of Wendell Berry
At St. John’s College in Annapolis, my alma mater, there was a story—apocryphal or not—that served as a guiding light to some of us. The Naval Academy, which is across the street from St. John’s, tried to requisition the campus sometime in the 1940s. They needed the land as part of the war effort. It fell to Jacob Klein, a legendary St. John’s tutor and dean who had fled Germany in the 1930s, to object. So, he walked over to the Naval Academy and asked to speak to the admiral in charge. The admiral, who was in the middle of waging a war, saw Klein in and told him he had thirty seconds to explain why the Naval Academy should not seize the campus. Klein lit a match and a cigarette. He took a long drag. Then, after twenty-eight seconds, he rejoined: “Because without places like St. John’s, this country isn’t worth saving from the Nazis.”
Anton Barba-Kay, Havens for the Human
Everything feels unexpected, as if it is coming out of nowhere. Developments appear unconnected to the past, and indeed to each other. In the absence of a plausible historical narrative, people retreat into tribalism or conspiracy theories (perhaps both) to help them make sense of the pace of change, because the deeper currents that shape society over decades and centuries-what James Davison Hunter calls the cultural “climate, as op posed to the “weather”-are invisible to them. The results can be painful.
Andrew Wilson, Remaking the World
First world lender problems
10. Lenders backing SpaceX’s latest $43 billion debt package, which is secured by its advanced AI chips, have tried to bar Elon Musk from firing the collateral into space as part of his plan for orbital data centres. The world’s richest man has outlined ambitious plans to power AI models with data centres cooled by the vacuum of space. That will require packing satellites full of advanced chips. SpaceX has said it plans to use the chips involved in the debt deal on Earth. But lenders have expressed concerns that if the group later decided to shoot the valuable chips that underpin their loans into space, it would prevent them from reclaiming and selling the semiconductors in the event of a default, according to people familiar with the matter. It is uncertain whether the provision was included in the finalised documents. (Source: ft.com)
John Ellis, News Items
The election, one more time (at least)
I have been inclined to view the November 3 election almost exclusively as a refutation of Trump and the party that enables him with such mindless cheer, and I still think, considering the huge vote margins, that is most of the story.
But I confess that I probably have been underestimating the importance of the Democrats managing to fill so many contests with candidates who are not palpably crazy Wokesters. In the nationally, famous races, James Talarico probably came closest to the “crazy wokester” category (yes, I know he is a “seminarian,” but you’ve got to consider the denomination and what he actually said before politics force him to try retraction), and he had the great advantage of being up against one of the two most notorious snakes in all of American politics when voters were motivated by disgust with White House snake to take it out on Texas snake immediately.
Shorts
- Christian activists like Mr. Schilling said the Trump administration gave them few successes over the past two years beyond some executive orders, including one establishing the White House Faith Office and another on “anti-Christian bias.” / “There’s no signature achievement. There’s nothing,” Mr. Schilling said. “We squandered an opportunity.” (Elizabeth Dias, ‘We Squandered an Opportunity’: The Christian Right on Its Election Rout – The New York Times) I’m afraid they were fools for thinking that a lame-duck satyr and gambling magnate ever gave them any opportunity to squander.
- In society at large, aside from the ever-burgeoning dominance of consumerism and capitalism, nothing has replaced Christianity in providing for shared goods. The result is a de facto reliance on emotivist, individual preference to determine the good as such and a seemingly inexorable trend toward increasing permissiveness necessarily coupled with ever more insistent calls for toleration. (Brad S. Gregory, The Unintended Reformation)
- God created war so that Americans would learn geography. (Mark Twain, or maybe not)
- If you like reading about the creation of a standard pseudo-bird to be shot into jet engines to simulate bird strikes, this is for you. (Leah Libresco Sargent reviewing Kobuk the Destroyer) Well, I hadn’t thought about it, but it sounds kind of fun.
- Charisma can be just as repellent as it is attractive, so it usually baffles or disgusts anyone not under its thrall. (Molly Worthen) Is this the explanation for the polarization between MAGA and Never-Trump? (They say Trump has charisma.)
Elsewhere in Tipsyworld
There is no crime, absolutely none, that cannot be condoned when ‘our’ side commits it.
I don’t do any of the major social media, but I have two sub-domains of the domain you’re currently reading: (a) You can read most of my reflexive stuff, especially political here. (b) I also post some things on my favorite no-algorithm social medium.